Welcome and, of course, Ground Rules

Lee · 29th May 2014, 02:44 PM

Ever so often a new thread appears that is off-topic as per arms and armour, but of potentially significant interest to our community. Such threads are a challenge to the Moderation Team; lock and enforce focus or look aside and hope not to get called out?

What you are invited to post here:

Ethnographic items other than arms & armour, particularly those of cultures whose arms & armour are discussed here.
Trends and issues relating to collecting ethnographic artifacts (please be cautious and stay away from flame-war politics).

Ultimately, for the time being, this forum is a test. The Moderation Team hopes this will evolve into a useful and interesting facet of our on-line community.

Jim McDougall · 29th May 2014, 08:50 PM

I just wanted to note that this new forum is an ideal solution to respond to occasional need to discuss items of material culture ancillary to the arms often discussed here. In many cases items which are not technically weapons are sometimes included as 'kit' such as ammunition cases or other accoutrements, or could well extend to items including anything material which might carry certain motif or decoration similar to that found on arms.

I can recall many cases where certain huqqa (vases or containers) or ewers etc and many Mamluk trays and utensils often reflect the designs and art so profoundly displayed in their metalwork.

There are also many oceanic items which are used in utilitarian context which are readily used as weapons, such as large paddles or spoons if I recall, Vandoo is the expert on these things!

I hope this forum will prove successful and respectfully ask that good judgement will prevail, as I am confident it will, if I know you guys!
No 'roadshow' stuff OK? you know...doilies, tea cups

?

A. G. Maisey · 7th June 2014, 01:27 PM

Love the idea!!!

29th May 2014, 02:44 PM	#1
Lee EAAF Staff Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: Upstate New York, USA Posts: 917	Welcome and, of course, Ground Rules Ever so often a new thread appears that is off-topic as per arms and armour, but of potentially significant interest to our community. Such threads are a challenge to the Moderation Team; lock and enforce focus or look aside and hope not to get called out? *What you are invited to post here:* Ethnographic items other than arms & armour, particularly those of cultures whose arms & armour are discussed here. Trends and issues relating to collecting ethnographic artifacts (please be cautious and stay away from flame-war politics). Ultimately, for the time being, this forum is a test. The Moderation Team hopes this will evolve into a useful and interesting facet of our on-line community.

29th May 2014, 08:50 PM	#2
Jim McDougall Arms Historian Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Route 66 Posts: 9,970	I just wanted to note that this new forum is an ideal solution to respond to occasional need to discuss items of material culture ancillary to the arms often discussed here. In many cases items which are not technically weapons are sometimes included as 'kit' such as ammunition cases or other accoutrements, or could well extend to items including anything material which might carry certain motif or decoration similar to that found on arms. I can recall many cases where certain huqqa (vases or containers) or ewers etc and many Mamluk trays and utensils often reflect the designs and art so profoundly displayed in their metalwork. There are also many oceanic items which are used in utilitarian context which are readily used as weapons, such as large paddles or spoons if I recall, Vandoo is the expert on these things! I hope this forum will prove successful and respectfully ask that good judgement will prevail, as I am confident it will, if I know you guys! No 'roadshow' stuff OK? you know...doilies, tea cups ?

7th June 2014, 01:27 PM	#3
A. G. Maisey Member Join Date: May 2006 Posts: 6,923	Love the idea!!!