Where are they from?:-)))

ariel · 1st February 2017, 07:44 PM

Recently sold on e-bay.
Presented as " Middle East, Afghanistan, Persia" and " Indo-Persian, Persian"

Who knows where in fact they are from?
I do:-)))

Jim McDougall · 1st February 2017, 08:56 PM

On the left like a bichaq, and the right of course Khyber, but both have unusual mounts.

Ian · 1st February 2017, 09:50 PM

Hmm...gee...errr...Pakistan?

There have been so many conquering hordes pass through Pakistan, they must have left behind knives like these at some time that were then adopted by the locals. Indo-Persian and Khyber knives are found in neighboring countries. Seems like the right part of the world to me.

Ian.

ALEX · 2nd February 2017, 12:10 PM

Ariel, the one on the left is "Turkmen from Syria". See THIS THREAD
The second is Central Asian, could be Afghanistan/Pakistan of course, but looks more Turkmen/Bukharan.

kronckew · 2nd February 2017, 01:01 PM

i tend to agree with alex on this set.

Lee · 2nd February 2017, 02:15 PM

The top one (brown background) is, I have been led to believe, Kurdish.

Oliver Pinchot · 2nd February 2017, 04:14 PM

There is no stylistic connection with Turkmen work whatsoever in the knife on the left. I saw many of these in Turkish museums while doing graduate research there. They are always labeled the same, Kürt bıçağı (Kurdish Knife.) Some show better workmanship than others, however they are all quite
similar in hilt composition.
That said, if Ariel is able to show otherwise, I look forward to reading it.

ALEX · 2nd February 2017, 04:56 PM

Oliver, this may not be Turkmen kard in terms of location, but one theory is that this type was made by Turkmen (or possibly other Central Asian) people living in Syria. This is solely an unproven theory and this could be any ethnic group in the region including Kurds. However, these knifes are not well known to be Kurdish (to me

. Many have re-purposed blades from other weapons which could be an indication of whoever produced them not having easy access or means to producing their own, i.e. a minority group living in a foreign land. I believe Kurds had some access and means resulting in better defined style such as their trademark and relatively uniform "Kurdish Jambiya". Again, just an unsubstantiated thought.

ariel · 3rd February 2017, 05:56 PM

Turkmen.

The one on the left was extensively discussed quite some time ago on a Russian forum
http://forum.guns.ru/forummessage/79/1724159-5.html

They also discussed Kurdish, Syrian etc. origins , but all was based on "personal gut feelings". For me the most persuasive argument was a book page from a German book, where this construction of the handle was attributed to Northern Afghanistan ( likely Turkmen territory), Teke tribe. See also Alex's reference to identical knives attributed to Turkmenistan by Artzi Yarom and AshokaArts.

The "khyber" like knife can be attributed with higher degree of precision: see picture taken from an article by Yu. Botyakov and V. Yanborisov " Turkmeni Weapons"
The leftmost 4 images contain a picture of an identical dagger. They belong to the largest Turkmen tribe Teke, concentrating in the south of the countru, on the border with Afghanistan. Please pay attention to the pommel: just a cap. Very reminiscent to the handles on the earliest Ottoman yataghans of Bayazet and Suleiman and later Uzbek royal examples.
Equally intriguing, IMHO, is the rightmost image : "eared" pommel. This is a Saryk knife. Boldly assuming that this feature is of ancestral origin ( I am skating on a thin ice here!) , can we tie it to the classical yataghan characteristics?

1st February 2017, 07:44 PM	#1
ariel Member Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Ann Arbor, MI Posts: 5,503	Where are they from?:-))) Recently sold on e-bay. Presented as " Middle East, Afghanistan, Persia" and " Indo-Persian, Persian" Who knows where in fact they are from? I do:-))) Attached Images

1st February 2017, 09:50 PM	#3
Ian Vikingsword Staff Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: The Aussie Bush Posts: 4,204	Hmm...gee...errr...Pakistan? There have been so many conquering hordes pass through Pakistan, they must have left behind knives like these at some time that were then adopted by the locals. Indo-Persian and Khyber knives are found in neighboring countries. Seems like the right part of the world to me. Ian. Last edited by Ian; 2nd February 2017 at 06:33 AM.

2nd February 2017, 04:56 PM	#8
ALEX Member Join Date: Jan 2006 Posts: 936	Oliver, this may not be Turkmen kard in terms of location, but one theory is that this type was made by Turkmen (or possibly other Central Asian) people living in Syria. This is solely an unproven theory and this could be any ethnic group in the region including Kurds. However, these knifes are not well known to be Kurdish (to me. Many have re-purposed blades from other weapons which could be an indication of whoever produced them not having easy access or means to producing their own, i.e. a minority group living in a foreign land. I believe Kurds had some access and means resulting in better defined style such as their trademark and relatively uniform "Kurdish Jambiya". Again, just an unsubstantiated thought. Last edited by ALEX; 2nd February 2017 at 05:12 PM.

3rd February 2017, 05:56 PM	#9
ariel Member Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Ann Arbor, MI Posts: 5,503	Turkmen. The one on the left was extensively discussed quite some time ago on a Russian forum http://forum.guns.ru/forummessage/79/1724159-5.html They also discussed Kurdish, Syrian etc. origins , but all was based on "personal gut feelings". For me the most persuasive argument was a book page from a German book, where this construction of the handle was attributed to Northern Afghanistan ( likely Turkmen territory), Teke tribe. See also Alex's reference to identical knives attributed to Turkmenistan by Artzi Yarom and AshokaArts. The "khyber" like knife can be attributed with higher degree of precision: see picture taken from an article by Yu. Botyakov and V. Yanborisov " Turkmeni Weapons" The leftmost 4 images contain a picture of an identical dagger. They belong to the largest Turkmen tribe Teke, concentrating in the south of the countru, on the border with Afghanistan. Please pay attention to the pommel: just a cap. Very reminiscent to the handles on the earliest Ottoman yataghans of Bayazet and Suleiman and later Uzbek royal examples. Equally intriguing, IMHO, is the rightmost image : "eared" pommel. This is a Saryk knife. Boldly assuming that this feature is of ancestral origin ( I am skating on a thin ice here!) , can we tie it to the classical yataghan characteristics? Attached Images

1st February 2017, 08:56 PM	#2
Jim McDougall Arms Historian Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Route 66 Posts: 9,955	On the left like a bichaq, and the right of course Khyber, but both have unusual mounts.

2nd February 2017, 12:10 PM	#4
ALEX Member Join Date: Jan 2006 Posts: 936	Ariel, the one on the left is "Turkmen from Syria". See THIS THREAD The second is Central Asian, could be Afghanistan/Pakistan of course, but looks more Turkmen/Bukharan.

2nd February 2017, 01:01 PM	#5
kronckew Member Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: Room 101, Glos. UK Posts: 4,184	i tend to agree with alex on this set.

2nd February 2017, 02:15 PM	#6
Lee EAAF Staff Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: Upstate New York, USA Posts: 914	The top one (brown background) is, I have been led to believe, Kurdish.

2nd February 2017, 04:14 PM	#7
Oliver Pinchot Member Join Date: Sep 2012 Posts: 457	There is no stylistic connection with Turkmen work whatsoever in the knife on the left. I saw many of these in Turkish museums while doing graduate research there. They are always labeled the same, Kürt bıçağı (Kurdish Knife.) Some show better workmanship than others, however they are all quite similar in hilt composition. That said, if Ariel is able to show otherwise, I look forward to reading it.