Tool or dagger?

[fernando]

Welcome to the forum, Jussi .
You have failed to upload the pictures .

[karloj]

Hope it works

[fernando]

Interesting piece. Can we call this a stiletto ?
With this type of blade (three faced?), the edges don't need to be sharp. It is sufficiently lethal when you thrust it.

[Atlantia]

Hi Karloj
Welcome to the forums.
This interesting piece looks like it may have been a sharpening 'steel' to me.

I've seen antique examples with round steels 'blades', facetted blades and blades of crosss section similar to yours.
Often they became worn over time and sometimes they get 'made over'

Does it have a hard temper?

[Atlantia]

Have a look here:
http://www.allaboutpocketknives.com/...p?f=41&t=24869

It's suprising how 'dagger like' some can be. Just a light reworking and hey presto!

[theswordcollector]

Originally Posted by fernando

Welcome to the forum, Jussi .
You have failed to upload the pictures .

Hi this is a knife sharpening tool for a butcher or kitchen tool . I am 100% postive .It is not a dagger. They are not commonly seen so people mistake
them for daggers but it is an early kitchen tool. Take care

[karloj]

Greetings
Thank you very much fernando, Atlantia, cornelistromp and theswordcollector.

It seems, that Atlantia and theswordcollector think I's a sharpening steel.

Am I right, and what Atlantia also asked me, that the key feature in sharpening steel is that it is very hard ? The steel have to be very high carbon steel to quench it very hard. The surface of the sharpening tool, grooved or slick, has to be very hard. I think (If I have understood right, that quenching is making steel hard and tempering is making steel for instance more flexible after quenching) sharpening steel is not tempered at all, so it is very hard and it breaks quite easily.

Well, I do not have any means to measure hardness of the blade, Rockwell or any else scale.

So, If it is sharpening steel, the marks in the blade had to be engraved or chiseled before the quenching the blade. There is no any factory markings or any stamped marks in the blade. These engraved marks look quite primitive to me and I don't believe, that these are any factory made. Also there is many scratches in the blade, so I don't think that the surface of the blade is exceptionally hard.

Or if it is a fake, it must be tempered again in that degree that it is soft enough to grind and engrave it. Well, it's maybe easier to do a new dagger altogether and add also the thumb guard which is missing.

Thank you especially cornelistromp from putting reference in your message. It was very thrilling to read your learned opinion.

Atlantia for idea and links concerning sharpening steel. That idea I must think carefully.

I would like to ask theswordcollector, if he is 100% sure that it is sharpening steel, what are the grounds for such strong opinion? It would be very nice to get 100% correct identification.

Fernando, the blades crosscut is actually diamant.

Jussi

Post scriptum. I ask you not to pay too much attention to my English. My original language is Finnish and I hope you understand what I am trying to say.

[fernando]

Originally Posted by karloj

... Fernando, the blades crosscut is actually diamant...

Which makes it (even) more probable to be a stiletto dagger !!

Originally Posted by karloj

... I hope you understand what I am trying to say... [/I]

Completely; my english is not better .

[Atlantia]

If it is a sharpening steel, diamond section and multi-faced blades are not uncommon.
The shape and large size of this piece suggest that origin to me.
But I could be wrong. It appears to have been extensively reworked/cleaned

[Gavin Nugent]

To my eye it is a cut down small sword....

[karloj]

Originally Posted by freebooter

To my eye it is a cut down small sword....

Hello freebooter

I think that it is too small to be cut down small sword.
Here is for the comparison these two. The sword is Swedish infantry officers sword pattern 1790.

I found this picture from the net. It is part of larger picture so it is very poor quality. The text didn't mentioned it other but that is about 15th or 16th century. I don't put link, because it is in antique traders page.

Of course it's not identical, but some features are alike. And, Atlantia, it is possible, that it is a sharpening steel but it is also possible that it is not. It is possible, that it's not either, but something else altogether. That is what I am doing, searching for proof for identification.