Italian broadsword, 1500s-1600s ?

[Gavin Nugent]

A ponerdous piece, something I recently saw for sale....did you buy it?

Not Italian in my eyes at all, whilst 'work horse' examples' are sure to be found, I have rarely seen any Italian sword lacking in a certain 'flare' in consistancy and quality even in the 'users' not seen in high end books.

This to me is too much of a hybrid combination of parts that points to East Africa under Arabian influnce in my eyes. The blade appears far to robust and large for an Oman Kattara, to my eyes a Kaskara blade.

I will ponder some more.

Gav

[Jim McDougall]

The article by North truly was a significant reference to understanding more on the ancestry of the Maghrebi sa'if, often referred to as the nimcha or Moroccan sa'if. This weapon reminds me of various 'working weapons' which were indeed put together in the weapons trade out of Zanzibar, the same rugged type workmanship using components, in this case a native kaskara blade.
Numbers of these swords included what was known as the 'Zanzibar' type nimcha ( Buttin) with the crossguard loop, and others with karabela type hilts, as well as this fabricated horn grip. It seems these were typically 19th century often using older components and blades, and most were sent into Yemen, where a wide array of these kinds of swords emerged. Also found in these regions were Ethiopian blades of straight broadsword style.

You're right Dmitry, the Boccia & Coelho book is a magnificent reference to classical styles which seem to have influenced many sword types, in particular in North Africa reflecting the long tradition of trade between North Italy and there. An outstanding book that does show us the 'workhorses' and everyday weapons really used is Tirri, an excellent collectors guidebook to the kinds of everyday weapons that often do turn up unexpectedly in sales and auctions.

A sturdy and most interesting example of the working weapons of Arabia in mid to latter 19th century into the early 20th, often rugged composites in times of high adventure from East Africa, the Red Sea and Yemen.

All best regards,
Jim

[Dmitry]

Originally Posted by freebooter

A ponerdous piece, something I recently saw for sale....did you buy it?

It was in one of the US auctions recently. I didn't bid on it, just saved the photos. It was mislabeled as a European 18th century sword.

Indeed, Jim! Stylistically, I think it's right out of 16th c. North Italian/Venetian vernacular.

[stephen wood]

...very interesting. Does look like a kaskara blade and the crossguard has the X.

By the way, Anthony North was at this month's Arms and Armour Society meeting - he was presented with the Society's Medal.