Chinese weapons or potato masher and a fireplace tool

josh stout · 23rd April 2010, 03:00 PM

These ones are tough. Overall, the shapes and proportions seem slightly off, but Chinese things like these are often idiosyncratic. The mace head seems slightly too big, and the hook shape is wrong. It is a bit too wide. The barbed spear shape tip is not something I have seen on antiques, but is not uncommon on fakes.

That said, as pointed out, the faceted shaft on the gou (hook) is something I previously would have said is an indication of a genuine antique. Also the faceted "nuts" on the handle appear very good.

Josh

kino · 25th April 2010, 04:41 PM

Josh, thanks for your input. Now I really am confused

t_c · 25th April 2010, 05:57 PM

Hey Kino (and Josh), maybe I can help with the confusion. I think I have handled these - did you find them in a bucket on 13th in stumptown?
If these are the same ones, they seemed fairly authentic to me IMHO - in hand they felt "right". I think that shop tends to clean up the the older, more beat up stuff they get (just an observation - not judging them for it). That could explain why they might seem a little weird (proportions off, etc). It looks like the blade and mace heads were ground new to make the piece "sellable", while the shafts were given less attention to show the age. This might explain the "barbs" on the spear head. If it was deeply rusted at the base of the point, I suspect someone just took it to a grinder or belt sander - it looks like the "barbs" could be "steps" made with a grinder (a little misguided creativity in cleaning it up). It's been a long time since I handled them, and I'm speculating on the pictures. Is there any indication of this on closer inspection?

If I had had more money I would've bought them when I saw them, picked up a couple of different pieces instead, but I still really like these guys

. Nice pieces.

kino · 25th April 2010, 06:23 PM

t_c, I did find them in a bucket on 13th. I don't know if the area is called Stumptown. I just happened to drive by the store on my way to getting lost.
Are you from that area?

t_c · 25th April 2010, 06:44 PM

I lived there years ago - stopped by the shop last summer when I was up visiting friends. "Stumptown" is just a nickname for Portland (logging reference), but that neighborhood is Sellwood.
Getting lost is a good thing sometimes

23rd April 2010, 03:00 PM	#1
josh stout Member Join Date: Mar 2007 Posts: 407	These ones are tough. Overall, the shapes and proportions seem slightly off, but Chinese things like these are often idiosyncratic. The mace head seems slightly too big, and the hook shape is wrong. It is a bit too wide. The barbed spear shape tip is not something I have seen on antiques, but is not uncommon on fakes. That said, as pointed out, the faceted shaft on the gou (hook) is something I previously would have said is an indication of a genuine antique. Also the faceted "nuts" on the handle appear very good. Josh

25th April 2010, 04:41 PM	#2
kino Member Join Date: Dec 2004 Posts: 1,018	Josh, thanks for your input. Now I really am confused

25th April 2010, 05:57 PM	#3
t_c Member Join Date: Jun 2006 Location: ca, usa Posts: 92	Hey Kino (and Josh), maybe I can help with the confusion. I think I have handled these - did you find them in a bucket on 13th in stumptown? If these are the same ones, they seemed fairly authentic to me IMHO - in hand they felt "right". I think that shop tends to clean up the the older, more beat up stuff they get (just an observation - not judging them for it). That could explain why they might seem a little weird (proportions off, etc). It looks like the blade and mace heads were ground new to make the piece "sellable", while the shafts were given less attention to show the age. This might explain the "barbs" on the spear head. If it was deeply rusted at the base of the point, I suspect someone just took it to a grinder or belt sander - it looks like the "barbs" could be "steps" made with a grinder (a little misguided creativity in cleaning it up). It's been a long time since I handled them, and I'm speculating on the pictures. Is there any indication of this on closer inspection? If I had had more money I would've bought them when I saw them, picked up a couple of different pieces instead, but I still really like these guys . Nice pieces.

25th April 2010, 06:23 PM	#4
kino Member Join Date: Dec 2004 Posts: 1,018	t_c, I did find them in a bucket on 13th. I don't know if the area is called Stumptown. I just happened to drive by the store on my way to getting lost. Are you from that area?

25th April 2010, 06:44 PM	#5
t_c Member Join Date: Jun 2006 Location: ca, usa Posts: 92	I lived there years ago - stopped by the shop last summer when I was up visiting friends. "Stumptown" is just a nickname for Portland (logging reference), but that neighborhood is Sellwood. Getting lost is a good thing sometimes