THE REAL DEAL!

elevennevele · 12th August 2007, 04:50 AM

don't get me started!

elevennevele · 12th August 2007, 06:55 AM

Actually, on a serious note, the Roman did make their way up into England though I believe they never made their way up north where the Picts fought against them. I recall seeing Roman ruins in England a long time ago. Also, didn't they just uncover a more recent Roman find?

None of this however would support the claims on that sword.

kronckew · 12th August 2007, 09:48 AM

arabic inscriptions look just like ruinic

obviously kaskara are a very early form if found in roman britain.

maybe he can 'discover' it was actually excalibur!

on another note, hadrian's wall , built to mark and control trade at the northern border between the roman and celtic britains was dotted with forts, one of them, Vindolanda, they recently found an underground armoury with examples of what we call Lorica segmentata , as well as a lot of other stuff they are still meticulously sorting thru. they also found a lot of ordinary letters that had been thrown out onto the rubbish heap & partially burned. one of which was a letter where a legionnaire had written home for his family to send him some warm woolen socks and some new underpants. they have found a number of grave markers, one of which was in latin and aramaic where a syrian auxilliary centurion posted to the wall mourned the death of his british wife. rome was the original 'melting pot' of cultures. the wall was mainly manned by auxilliaries from all over the empire after they replaced the legions that originally built it.

the recent King Arthur (2004) movie gives a flavour of life on the wall as rome abandoned its borders and drew in on itself. just don't take it too literally. the arms and armour while gussied up by hollywood were not bad, and i liked the drako standard arturus uses.

p.s. - i've got the 'director's cut' dvd's on my desk as i type, think i'll watch it again now that i'm thinking of it....

Bill M · 12th August 2007, 03:30 PM

What? You seem to think this is not authentic?

I am sure I saw Persian elite shock troops using them in "The 300." We all know THAT was a worthwhile and historically correct movie!

Somehow my wife liked the movie better than me.

Oh well,let's all chant SPAR--TAH!

Bill
iPhone Message

rand · 12th August 2007, 03:49 PM

Hey Bill,

300 was based on a comic book...... But I wish they would have done a historically accurate version, believe it to be a better story and would certainly hold my interest longer.

Saw that the Seller posted correct information when notified....

rand

Bill M · 12th August 2007, 04:38 PM

Hi Rand,

Knew it was based on a comic book I was just hoping for more.

Still don't see this sword being valuable. "Interesting" scabbard and dress, but more of a curiosity.

Battara · 12th August 2007, 07:24 PM

So...what everyone is saying is that the Celts did not make it to Africa?

Jim McDougall · 12th August 2007, 08:09 PM

Although this might have been just another example of blatant misidentification as often seen on many items that appear on ebay it evidences the unbelievable unfamiliarity with weapons by the general public. It seems with the computer search potential that a simple effort would at least give people the idea of where to look further.

While obviously the description exceeds the basic fantasy material, it is interesting to see one of these Nilotic kaskaras, and thankfully it actually went for a reasonable price without a frenzy thinking this was Excalibur!!

I have often wondered if these crocodile hide covered weapons actually were mounted contemporarily with some sort of totemic value observed by tribal warriors, or whether these were produced to satisfy curious tourists of the post-Mahdist period. In efforts to discuss the use of crocodile hide and the possibilities of such association over the years, the results were consistantly disappointing, and in some cases produced unwarranted negativity.

In discussions with one young man who had come from Darfur, he did note that use of the totemic associations with feared animals was indeed in some degree practiced among warriors and would explain such use of crocodile etc. That is of course just one note from one person, though well qualified.I have seen examples of kaskara mounted much like this but with much older and formidable blades, suggesting mounting of 19th c. The example I refer to had hilt mounts consistant with those found on Darfur weapons (Briggs).The blade on this example seems more likely 20th c.

While continued discussion on this topic would be interesting and always hopefully productive, I realize it is as noted, unlikely. Regardless, I thought I would add these notes for anyone interested in furthering what we know about these intriguing examples of kaskara.

With best regards,
Jim

12th August 2007, 09:48 AM	#3
kronckew Member Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: Room 101, Glos. UK Posts: 4,215	arabic inscriptions look just like ruinic obviously kaskara are a very early form if found in roman britain. maybe he can 'discover' it was actually excalibur! on another note, hadrian's wall , built to mark and control trade at the northern border between the roman and celtic britains was dotted with forts, one of them, Vindolanda, they recently found an underground armoury with examples of what we call Lorica segmentata , as well as a lot of other stuff they are still meticulously sorting thru. they also found a lot of ordinary letters that had been thrown out onto the rubbish heap & partially burned. one of which was a letter where a legionnaire had written home for his family to send him some warm woolen socks and some new underpants. they have found a number of grave markers, one of which was in latin and aramaic where a syrian auxilliary centurion posted to the wall mourned the death of his british wife. rome was the original 'melting pot' of cultures. the wall was mainly manned by auxilliaries from all over the empire after they replaced the legions that originally built it. the recent King Arthur (2004) movie gives a flavour of life on the wall as rome abandoned its borders and drew in on itself. just don't take it too literally. the arms and armour while gussied up by hollywood were not bad, and i liked the drako standard arturus uses. p.s. - i've got the 'director's cut' dvd's on my desk as i type, think i'll watch it again now that i'm thinking of it.... Last edited by kronckew; 12th August 2007 at 09:59 AM.

12th August 2007, 03:49 PM	#5
rand Member Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: Virginia Posts: 539	300 Hey Bill, 300 was based on a comic book...... But I wish they would have done a historically accurate version, believe it to be a better story and would certainly hold my interest longer. Saw that the Seller posted correct information when notified.... rand

12th August 2007, 04:50 AM	#1
elevennevele Member Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: Canada Posts: 11	don't get me started!

12th August 2007, 06:55 AM	#2
elevennevele Member Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: Canada Posts: 11	Actually, on a serious note, the Roman did make their way up into England though I believe they never made their way up north where the Picts fought against them. I recall seeing Roman ruins in England a long time ago. Also, didn't they just uncover a more recent Roman find? None of this however would support the claims on that sword.

12th August 2007, 03:30 PM	#4
Bill M Member Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: USA Georgia Posts: 1,599	What? You seem to think this is not authentic? I am sure I saw Persian elite shock troops using them in "The 300." We all know THAT was a worthwhile and historically correct movie! Somehow my wife liked the movie better than me. Oh well,let's all chant SPAR--TAH! Bill iPhone Message

12th August 2007, 04:38 PM	#6
Bill M Member Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: USA Georgia Posts: 1,599	Hi Rand, Knew it was based on a comic book I was just hoping for more. Still don't see this sword being valuable. "Interesting" scabbard and dress, but more of a curiosity.

12th August 2007, 07:24 PM	#7
Battara EAAF Staff Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Louisville, KY Posts: 7,270	So...what everyone is saying is that the Celts did not make it to Africa?

12th August 2007, 08:09 PM	#8
Jim McDougall Arms Historian Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Route 66 Posts: 10,189	Although this might have been just another example of blatant misidentification as often seen on many items that appear on ebay it evidences the unbelievable unfamiliarity with weapons by the general public. It seems with the computer search potential that a simple effort would at least give people the idea of where to look further. While obviously the description exceeds the basic fantasy material, it is interesting to see one of these Nilotic kaskaras, and thankfully it actually went for a reasonable price without a frenzy thinking this was Excalibur!! I have often wondered if these crocodile hide covered weapons actually were mounted contemporarily with some sort of totemic value observed by tribal warriors, or whether these were produced to satisfy curious tourists of the post-Mahdist period. In efforts to discuss the use of crocodile hide and the possibilities of such association over the years, the results were consistantly disappointing, and in some cases produced unwarranted negativity. In discussions with one young man who had come from Darfur, he did note that use of the totemic associations with feared animals was indeed in some degree practiced among warriors and would explain such use of crocodile etc. That is of course just one note from one person, though well qualified.I have seen examples of kaskara mounted much like this but with much older and formidable blades, suggesting mounting of 19th c. The example I refer to had hilt mounts consistant with those found on Darfur weapons (Briggs).The blade on this example seems more likely 20th c. While continued discussion on this topic would be interesting and always hopefully productive, I realize it is as noted, unlikely. Regardless, I thought I would add these notes for anyone interested in furthering what we know about these intriguing examples of kaskara. With best regards, Jim