Kris naga

A. G. Maisey · 30th May 2021, 09:44 PM

Jean, I cannot see sufficient in these photos to take a guess at origin, but I do find the trifolate greneng features interesting. This type of greneng has been noted in some very old blades. My feeling is East Jawa, this is not a guess, not an opinion, it is a feeling.

Jean · 31st May 2021, 08:59 AM

Thank you Alan, I will send better pic as soon as I can.

Athanase · 31st May 2021, 11:21 AM

Hello,

I have already seen this style of handle 2 or 3 times sometimes with more basic Kriss blades. The patina and finish of the handles reminded me of something from the second half of the 20th century and at least one of the associated kriss blades was from the same period with certainty.
It is because of these doubts about the age of the handle (and also a little bit of the blade, the photos in the sale are not good) that I did not bid.

Jean · 31st May 2021, 02:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Athanase

Hello,

I have already seen this style of handle 2 or 3 times sometimes with more basic Kriss blades. The patina and finish of the handles reminded me of something from the second half of the 20th century and at least one of the associated kriss blades was from the same period with certainty.
It is because of these doubts about the age of the handle (and also a little bit of the blade, the photos in the sale are not good) that I did not bid.

Well, to me this blade does not look like the recent naga blades from Madura but I will confirm upon receipt. Your opinion is the third one which I received (plus my own), and all are different! Regarding the hilt, my concern is more whether it is suitable for a kris than its age, but again I will confirm.

David · 31st May 2021, 04:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jean

Regarding the hilt, my concern is more whether it is suitable for a kris than its age, but again I will confirm.

Well, i couldn't say for sure that this hilt isn't suitable for any keris. My early response in regards to this was only to say that a hilt can never really be used as an indication of the origin of the blade, unless we can be sure that it has been with that blade since the very beginning. And even then the origin of the hilt cannot be guaranteed to identify the origin of the blade.

I will wait for better images of this blade before making any comments on age, though i'm not sure that the trifolate greneng Alan remarked upon guarantees this to be a blade of any particular age since keris makers often copy older styles in later works. The seller's photos are certainly not clear enough to make any definitive remarks on the age, though unless this keris was in some European collection for a very long time i wouldn't suspect it to be of any great age.

Jean · 31st May 2021, 05:17 PM

Thank you gentlemen. My Solonese friend who is experienced in the kris trade seems to have a quite definite opinion about the blade origin but I prefer to receive the piece and post pics before sharing it with you. Regarding the hilt, he says that this type of cast brass hilt is normally used for walking or commando sticks, although he saw few fitted on krisses or daggers.

A. G. Maisey · 31st May 2021, 10:33 PM

Jean, it would be very easy to form a firm opinion about this blade & hilt, the overall condition is pristine, the hilt is not a keris hilt and could not possibly be used as the hilt of a keris for either wear or in past times as a weapon, the overall style of workmanship is Madura, Sumenep, but having said that we must be aware that there are some craftsmen in East Jawa now, particularly around Malang, who have their roots buried deep in Madura.

I do not feel that this is an old keris, there are too many tells that place it into the second half of the 20th century. However, from the early 20th century through to at least the 1990's there were a few not particularly prolific craftsmen in Jogja and across to the east who were doing similar work to this. As far as I know the last of these men passed away about 20 to 25 years ago.

If this hilt is brass, either cast or fabricated, yes, it certainly does belong on a stok komando, probably not a walking stick, it is for display only, not for any kind of practical use.

As I said, it would be easy to form a firm opinion based upon these photos, but in the absence the item itself, in the hand, it could be very difficult indeed to provide a supportable opinion.

This is the reason that I used the word "feeling".

30th May 2021, 09:44 PM	#1
A. G. Maisey Member Join Date: May 2006 Posts: 6,989	Jean, I cannot see sufficient in these photos to take a guess at origin, but I do find the trifolate greneng features interesting. This type of greneng has been noted in some very old blades. My feeling is East Jawa, this is not a guess, not an opinion, it is a feeling.

31st May 2021, 08:59 AM	#2
Jean Member Join Date: Jun 2009 Posts: 1,740	Thank you Alan, I will send better pic as soon as I can.

31st May 2021, 11:21 AM	#3
Athanase Member Join Date: Mar 2016 Location: Paris (France) Posts: 417	Hello, I have already seen this style of handle 2 or 3 times sometimes with more basic Kriss blades. The patina and finish of the handles reminded me of something from the second half of the 20th century and at least one of the associated kriss blades was from the same period with certainty. It is because of these doubts about the age of the handle (and also a little bit of the blade, the photos in the sale are not good) that I did not bid.

31st May 2021, 05:17 PM	#6
Jean Member Join Date: Jun 2009 Posts: 1,740	Thank you gentlemen. My Solonese friend who is experienced in the kris trade seems to have a quite definite opinion about the blade origin but I prefer to receive the piece and post pics before sharing it with you. Regarding the hilt, he says that this type of cast brass hilt is normally used for walking or commando sticks, although he saw few fitted on krisses or daggers.

31st May 2021, 10:33 PM	#7
A. G. Maisey Member Join Date: May 2006 Posts: 6,989	Jean, it would be very easy to form a firm opinion about this blade & hilt, the overall condition is pristine, the hilt is not a keris hilt and could not possibly be used as the hilt of a keris for either wear or in past times as a weapon, the overall style of workmanship is Madura, Sumenep, but having said that we must be aware that there are some craftsmen in East Jawa now, particularly around Malang, who have their roots buried deep in Madura. I do not feel that this is an old keris, there are too many tells that place it into the second half of the 20th century. However, from the early 20th century through to at least the 1990's there were a few not particularly prolific craftsmen in Jogja and across to the east who were doing similar work to this. As far as I know the last of these men passed away about 20 to 25 years ago. If this hilt is brass, either cast or fabricated, yes, it certainly does belong on a stok komando, probably not a walking stick, it is for display only, not for any kind of practical use. As I said, it would be easy to form a firm opinion based upon these photos, but in the absence the item itself, in the hand, it could be very difficult indeed to provide a supportable opinion. This is the reason that I used the word "feeling".