| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  18th October 2025, 06:09 PM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 12
		 
			Views: 4,307
		 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  18th October 2025, 02:17 PM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 12
		 
			Views: 4,307
		 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  1st June 2025, 01:36 PM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 15
		 
			Views: 28,896
		 
			
				 It is very possible. Usually in akhara, kalari,... 
 It is very possible. Usually in akhara, kalari, festivals and ceremonies any weapon made recently and even from aluminum or something else is used. So in the case of your sword, such a combination of...
 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  31st May 2025, 06:45 PM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 15
		 
			Views: 28,896
		 
			
				 Jim, thank you, you are right, this object is... 
 Jim, thank you, you are right, this object is from a "living" culture and was used as a weapon in traditional martial arts. And if the handle is new (19th-20th centuries), then the blade, as you...
 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  12th April 2025, 05:10 PM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 31
		 
			Views: 59,932
		 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  28th February 2025, 03:13 PM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 11
		 
			Views: 46,478
		 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  27th February 2025, 03:06 PM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 5
		 
			Views: 43,115
		 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  27th February 2025, 08:12 AM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 5
		 
			Views: 43,115
		 
			
				 This is an Indian and then an Indo-Muslim... 
 This is an Indian and then an Indo-Muslim feature. This is what animates the sword. The Indian weapon is a subject, not an object.
 
 But pearls in the blade (or their metal analogue) are already a...
 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  25th February 2025, 01:45 PM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 11
		 
			Views: 46,478
		 
			
				 Iron hilt of talwar and piso pedang 
 Colleagues, there is a problem of how to distinguish Indian iron talwar hilts with bowl-shaped pommels from similar hilts of piso pedang. Besides the size of the bowled-pommel itself there must be...
 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  16th January 2024, 02:13 PM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 58
		 
			Views: 108,048
		 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  16th January 2024, 11:57 AM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 58
		 
			Views: 108,048
		 
			
				 I think that Central Asian shashkas are just... 
 I think that Central Asian shashkas are just “cousins” of Caucasian (and later Russian) ones, and not a direct borrowing. They often resemble Khyber knives in design.
 The common ancestor of all...
 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  9th January 2024, 02:41 PM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 31
		 
			Views: 59,932
		 
			
				 The main problem is that in the Indian... 
 The main problem is that in the Indian subcontinent, proper names, unlike European languages, were used only for significant things. For everything else, general generic concepts or derivatives from...
 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  10th December 2023, 01:39 PM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 2
		 
			Views: 19,046
		 
			
				 Mazandaran dagger 
 I am sorry for Google translate:
 
 "... but the very first known image of such a dagger belonged to the Indian master Bishandas and was painted by him in 1616-1617, when he was in Persia, sent there...
 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  7th December 2023, 03:22 PM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 16
		 
			Views: 54,475
		 
			
				 Thank you very much!  
The point is that in... 
 Thank you very much!
 The point is that in origin all such items were sickles for agricultural work, as their names suggest.
 hansia - sickle
 Arival or aruval - sickle
 All other names that include...
 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  4th December 2023, 12:08 PM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 16
		 
			Views: 54,475
		 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  2nd December 2023, 02:32 PM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 8
		 
			Views: 26,776
		 
			
				 By the way, one more fact. Quite quickly, real... 
 By the way, one more fact. Quite quickly, real Chinese porcelain began to remain in Iran, and instead, Iranian copies began to be supplied to Europe. But Europe developed its own high art, but...
 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  2nd December 2023, 02:23 PM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 8
		 
			Views: 26,776
		 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  2nd December 2023, 02:20 PM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 8
		 
			Views: 26,776
		 
			
				 My research showed that the starting point was... 
 My research showed that the starting point was Chinese ceramics of the 14th and 15th centuries, and later porcelain supplied to Iran and beyond. After Iran, this element independently appears in the...
 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  2nd December 2023, 02:19 PM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 8
		 
			Views: 26,776
		 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  2nd December 2023, 02:04 PM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 8
		 
			Views: 26,776
		 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  2nd December 2023, 09:50 AM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 12
		 
			Views: 35,092
		 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  2nd December 2023, 09:47 AM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 12
		 
			Views: 35,092
		 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  2nd December 2023, 09:44 AM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 12
		 
			Views: 35,092
		 
			
				 I am sorry for Google translate:  
"...given that... 
 I am sorry for Google translate:
 "...given that Nepal was cut off from normal cultural connections with the rest of India in the early 13th century by the Muslim invasion of Bengal and Bihar, it can...
 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  26th July 2022, 03:29 PM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 16
		 
			Views: 46,193
		 
			
				 Sorry, I have to repeat the question:  
  
  
  
... 
 Sorry, I have to repeat the question:
 
 
 
 
 I have already tried to explain to you in several topics that it is impossible to study the history and history of weapons in particular using "a quick...
 | 
	| Forum: Ethnographic Weapons  26th July 2022, 02:41 PM | 
	
	| 
			Replies: 16
		 
			Views: 46,193
		 
			
				 Identical blades... Ok. The handle, as I... 
 Identical blades... Ok. The handle, as I understand it, was borrowed from the European rondel dagger, and some differences do not count?
 
 
 Very strange. On that forum you were told that the knife...
 |