A possible Schiavona ancestor

[Matchlock]

Oh come on, 'Nando,

I remember some fine stands you made - you could easily build Norman's!

Best,
Michl

[fernando]

It's not a question of putting one up, Michl, but that of a certain difficulty in acquiring the right raw materials .

[Matchlock]

Brilliant!!!! I'm afraid though I can't help you out either.

[fernando]

The sword has arrived.
No point in posting more pictures as, the ones already posted, copied from the seller's website, are rather good and faithful and i could do no better.
The point of balance is quite close to the hilt (4 cms.), naturaly due to both the intricate iron basket and (beautiful) pommel weight.
The fissure (crack) on the blade is not dramatic; is more uncomfortable to the eyes than to actual debilitation potential.
Nevertheless, i will conveniently adopt the term "old warrior" for this piece. Two of the hilt branch ends are loose, although the whole guard setup still feels rather solid. It also looks as if the blade was subject to a straightening process.
On the other hand, a sword of this category, in prime condition, would cost two to three times as much, an horizon i can't reach.
But overall it looks like a great piece, with its large slice of mystic.
Now, i would like to ask you guys for an opinion:
The problem is that i am not managing to digest the looks of that broken tip.
Bearing in mind that:
1 - The blade presently measures 84,5 cms (33") to the crossguard, or 80,5cms (32") to the hilt.
2 - Its fuller just about ends slightly before the broken tip end.
3 - Unless compared with a similar (equal) sword example is hard to know the length of the missingh part; some two inches ?
Question:
Would you try and reshape its tip?
... More pointy, more gothic, more round ?
Or should i just leave it as it is and get accomodated with time coming ?
Thanks for your cooperation.

.

[Iain]

Very nice sword, I've been admiring the pictures over the last couple days. I just wanted to quickly jump in to say, leave the tip as is!

I usually go through a process with almost every new purchase where I find something "wrong" and obsess about it for a few weeks. Then I stop noticing it over time.

I think trying to "fix" antiques is a slippery slope and re profiling the tip will just lead to the lose of material and disturbing a rather well developed patina.

Looks great to me as it is.

[kai]

Hello Fernando,

I'm with Iain here - at least wait for a while before deciding on any work.

Unless you contemplate to bring the whole blade to new polish and accept to reprofile the blade for a considerable part of its length (and then the hilt will most likely look off and possibly the blade crack worse), any local changes to the tip will probably make it look fake rather than better, I guess...

Regards,
Kai

[fernando]

Thanks a lot, Iain and Kai, for the wise words.
I am particulary glad that you like this sword, Iain.
Yes, i am going to give it some time, expecting this initial hysteria to vanish and the tip detail stops jumping into my eyes.
I hope she feels fine close to her hosts.

.

[cornelistromp]

Hi Fernando,

beautiful and rare sword, even with a broken point, congratulations!
it is not necessarily of Italian (Venetian?) origin.
you can see the hilt bar design similarities with the German basket hilted riding swords around mid 16thC , H and J.(Oakeshott attachment)
I personally would place the sword in the German direction and around 1540.

If you have an authentic blade point, you could consider a "justifiable" restoration.

I myself am a supporter to leave authentic weapons as much as possible untouched.

a fracture in the hilt , a grip, a broken blade can be restored, in all cases patina must remain untouched.

best,