Viking Sword in Norway: Lost & Found ?

[Rick]

http://www.msn.com/en-us/video/wonde...cid=spartandhp

[mariusgmioc]

It looks too good to be true to me.

Wouldn't want it in my collection as it has too many question marks attached.

[Will M]

I think the lack of centuries of corrosion tells it all.

[Rick]

But what if it had been in a glacial mass and had just melted out 100 years ago.
They're finding bodies in the Alps from 50 years ago or older these days; Iceman etc.
http://www.ancient-origins.net/news-...08760/page/0/1

[mariusgmioc]

Originally Posted by Rick

But what if it had been in a glacial mass and had just melted out 100 years ago.
They're finding bodies in the Alps from 50 years ago or older these days; Iceman etc.
http://www.ancient-origins.net/news-...08760/page/0/1

Even IF... then why isn't it together with the scales? Why would be the grip completely rotten away and the tang beneath almost intact? The very same process that consumed the scales, should have left its bite on the tang as well. At least that's my theory.

It may be a genuine find but... too many question marks for me.

[David]

I was skeptical at first, but it is being considered genuine by Norwegian archeologist and has been written up in reasonably legitimate publications.
http://www.torontosun.com/2017/09/14...gian-mountains
I'm not sure why you chose to post this in the miscellania section though. Seems like a good regular topic, especially for a website called Vikingsword.

[silberschatzimsee]

https://www.khm.uio.no/english/resea...ord_lesja.html

Here the official link with xrays and stuff

[Lee]

If that Viking sword just "showed up" in the antiques market, I'd be strongly inclined to dismiss it as a forgery. Known provenance and technical examination may be able to firmly establish its authenticity and exclude a hoax propelled by wishful thinking.

[silberschatzimsee]

I think that guy died there and maybe because of glaciers the sword moved to that position over the centuries.

[silberschatzimsee]

Or it was a joke from the localpub crew in 1900 for later people. Same like the famous Piltdown Man

[David]

It does seem from what i read that museums and archeologists are taking it rather seriously in Norway and do in fact consider it the real thing. At least none of the articles i have read suggest that it is a forgery.
I am going to add the words "Viking Sword" to the title to better attract the attention of other members.

[Lee]

Our 'local' variant of such a 19th century hoax was the Cardiff Giant. I have seen it and it is not at all convincing.

[Ibrahiim al Balooshi]

I think technology has advanced somewhat since 1869 however, I thought that was a fascinating story and well worth placing here... My point being that Norwegian Archaeology specialists are crediting this as genuine and presumably have run their special high tech tests to prove that~ thus are we not perhaps rather pre judging the issue ? My ex Mother in Law is 12 feet long!

[Rick]

Interesting about the differing ages of the blade and the cross guard.
I wonder if it might have been an heirloom incorporated with the newer blade for talismanic purposes.

This guy says it's real.

[silberschatzimsee]

Originally Posted by Lee

Our 'local' variant of such a 19th century hoax was the Cardiff Giant. I have seen it and it is not at all convincing.

Hahaha

My point being that Norwegian Archaeology specialists are crediting this as genuine and presumably have run their special high tech tests to prove that

Piltdown Man fooled the specialists for 50 years

No like i mentioned i believe the previous owner got lost, died in some snowstorm and the sword was moved by ice and erosion to its last position.