Where's the Wootz?

urbanspaceman · Yesterday, 08:31 PM

I find this a deep and impenetrable issue which has perplexed me from the start, and continues to do so, despite reading everything I can find, and now watching all the postings on Youtube.
This question I ask here is focused and coherent:

"Was the 'Crucible Method' used to produce steel in the Middle-East; as opposed to the common and typical 'billet-welding'.
Plus, are there examples of sword blades made from such steel, and how do we tell.

Pertinently, I am not talking about blades made from Wootz produced in India and Sri Lanka then exported along the Silk Roads; I refer, specifically, to crucible steel made in the Middle East.
Perhaps someone has absorbed and assimilated all the - often contradictory - theses out there. I hope so.
It has taken me a long time to firmly grasp the production method, but the above remains elusive.
With thanks in anticipation.
ps
Hi Jim.

Yesterday, 08:31 PM	#1
urbanspaceman Member Join Date: Sep 2017 Location: Tyneside. North-East England Posts: 533	Where's the Wootz? I find this a deep and impenetrable issue which has perplexed me from the start, and continues to do so, despite reading everything I can find, and now watching all the postings on Youtube. This question I ask here is focused and coherent: "Was the 'Crucible Method' used to produce steel in the Middle-East; as opposed to the common and typical 'billet-welding'. Plus, are there examples of sword blades made from such steel, and how do we tell. Pertinently, I am not talking about blades made from Wootz produced in India and Sri Lanka then exported along the Silk Roads; I refer, specifically, to crucible steel made in the Middle East. Perhaps someone has absorbed and assimilated all the - often contradictory - theses out there. I hope so. It has taken me a long time to firmly grasp the production method, but the above remains elusive. With thanks in anticipation. ps Hi Jim.