Celurit and an Arit Bendo (?)

A. G. Maisey · 18th September 2023, 09:27 PM

Looks like somebody else has seen the little knobs, even if I have not, so that is probably good enough to hang "Madura" on it.

But we should remember that even though some information appears in a number of sources, all those sources might come back to the same root, & that root can be incorrect or misunderstood.

As for who can be certain about any identification of anything --- & I'm not only thinking weapons & tools here --- I would say nobody can be, the name of something can change from one side of the street to the other. That's the case in Jawa, it seems less so in Bali, but my knowledge of Bali is not as strong as my knowledge of Jawa. As for other places throughout the Archipelago, I lack the necessary experience to form too many definite opinions at all.

18th September 2023, 09:27 PM	#5
A. G. Maisey Member Join Date: May 2006 Posts: 6,856	Looks like somebody else has seen the little knobs, even if I have not, so that is probably good enough to hang "Madura" on it. But we should remember that even though some information appears in a number of sources, all those sources might come back to the same root, & that root can be incorrect or misunderstood. As for who can be certain about any identification of anything --- & I'm not only thinking weapons & tools here --- I would say nobody can be, the name of something can change from one side of the street to the other. That's the case in Jawa, it seems less so in Bali, but my knowledge of Bali is not as strong as my knowledge of Jawa. As for other places throughout the Archipelago, I lack the necessary experience to form too many definite opinions at all.