29th July 2019, 09:59 AM | #31 | ||
Member
Join Date: Jun 2013
Posts: 2,145
|
Quote:
I wasn't mad but let's say more disapointed because "the other member" is precisely a respected and valued veteran member... Quote:
Where is the Greek if the maker is Ottoman Turkish and the user / owner Ottoman Tukish?? |
||
30th July 2019, 07:07 AM | #32 |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2014
Posts: 134
|
Perfect demonstration that this Greek origin is a nonsense.
Where is the Greek if the maker is Ottoman Turkish and the user / owner Ottoman Tukish?? [/QUOTE] The Greek is in region where this Ottoman Turkish owned and used his Yataghan. I am from Bulgaria, so is many generations of family, however I am not Bulgarian but rather Turkish. One of the many hundreds of thousand of Turks who were left behind when Ottoman Empire lost Bulgaria. Same happened with Greece. Bulgaria have tons of Yataghans , I have yet to see one Owens by a Slavic name, they are all inscribed to be owned by Turkish names, so are the makers. Same is true for “most” Greek yatagans too. |
30th November 2019, 01:06 AM | #33 |
Member
Join Date: May 2019
Posts: 153
|
This probably comes too late, but all the marks posted here say “Mustafa”
|
30th November 2019, 04:20 AM | #34 | |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2013
Posts: 2,145
|
Quote:
|
|
30th November 2019, 07:47 AM | #35 |
Member
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Ann Arbor, MI
Posts: 5,503
|
Ottoman Yataghans were assembled from mass-produced blades coming largely from Anatolia and Balkans ( Bosnia, mainly). Wherever they landed, their further fate was to fall into the hands of a local master who added the rest according to his local customs, tastes and traditions. This step defined the final product. That was the similar to the fate of other trade blades, such as Genoese, Styrian or generic Indian. Depending on the point of their final destination, they could be converted into Moroccan nimchas, Caucasian shashkas, Afghani pulwars, Mughals, Rajputs etc.
What is still original here is the blade ( generic “ Ottoman”) but a typical Greek/ Cretan crenellated niello silver tunkou/ Habaki- like appliqué at the root of the blade. That is all we have and all we can use in determining the ethnic origin of the final product. How do we interpret it depends on our discretion. We can take the “path of the least resistance” that was used by Gozde Yasar, for whom everything yataghanish was “Ottoman, period”, or try and discern local decorative peculiarities. The latter would point toward Crete. Finally, we are dealing not with certainties, but with probabilities. In a humongous and multiethnic Ottoman Empire nothing prevented a master of one ethnicity from using decorative technique of other people. That was a “ dime a dozen” approach in Imperial Russia with its multiethnic workshops geographically located in Tiflis and Vladikavkaz and spitting out thousands of “Caucasian” shashkas and kindjals of whatever ethnic pattern sold better at that moment or even creation of “Caucasian” - looking examples in St. Peterburg or Ukraine. Perhaps the most accurate definition of that yataghan would be “ Ottoman in a Cretan style”. |
30th November 2019, 05:16 PM | #36 |
Member
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Bay Area
Posts: 1,643
|
If we classify swords and daggers according to the blades, then all the swords with triple fullered Solingen 19th century blades from the Sahel are German. Obviously, not a very good approach, and as has been discussed here the mounts are generally a much better indicator on where a weapon was used.
|
30th November 2019, 06:22 PM | #37 | |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2013
Posts: 2,145
|
Quote:
200% The problem is that for you silver + niello = Greek when in fact it is Turkish Ottoman But i won't try to change your mind... |
|
30th November 2019, 06:56 PM | #38 | |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2013
Posts: 2,145
|
Quote:
http://vikingsword.com/vb/showthread.php?t=24813 |
|
30th November 2019, 09:01 PM | #39 |
Member
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Ann Arbor, MI
Posts: 5,503
|
Well, if you think that all things Ottoman are Turkish, that would greatly simplify your provenancing :-)
|
5th May 2020, 03:19 AM | #40 | |
Member
Join Date: May 2020
Posts: 772
|
Quote:
Didn't that happen as well when Celts, Anglosaxons, Germanic, Baltic and Scandinavion regions and peoples were converted as well...? So from a geographic point of view the name discussed might indeed be from an inhabitant of Greece. Let's not forget after the Balkan Wars of 1911-1913 a lot of resettlement took place in quite some countries in South East Europe and with this quite some names which were present for four to six centuries. Quite some edged weapons from Bosnia have the name Hassan on it, be it either the owner or maker's name.... And back on topic: the stamps / marks on the picture in cyrillic are the names Omar, Faruk, Rabomal Hasan, Rabomal Halu, Osman and Alu ( Alu being probably an elative case of Ali ) Last edited by gp; 6th May 2020 at 12:29 AM. |
|
8th May 2020, 10:23 PM | #41 |
Member
Join Date: May 2019
Posts: 153
|
The maker's name in the mark is 'Mustafa'
|
16th May 2020, 09:06 PM | #42 |
Member
Join Date: May 2020
Posts: 772
|
Some additional reading :
http://www.muzej-senj.hr/web/media/K...VO-GMS-web.pdf http://www.muzej.mod.gov.rs/en/museu...n#.XsAnQMDgo2x Some more visualisations (13 pictures actually from last year's exhibition) by the Bosnian institute in Sarajevo BiH : https://www.klix.ba/magazin/kultura/...ozbi/180418111 Click on the foto to get access to all 13 pics and a few from Livo: http://www.fmgg-livno.com/postavi/zb...-vojne-opreme/ By the way... Sarajevo or Sarajewo or also sometimes written in older books as Serajewo: the name originates form 2 Turkish words: Saray Bosna, meaning castle or fortress at (the river) Bosna. Saray (Arabic: السراي; Turkish: sarayı, seray), with the variant saraya or seraya (السرايا), is a castle, palace or government building which was considered to have particular administrative importance in various parts of the former Ottoman Empire. Seray may also be spelt serail in English, via French influence, in which case the L is (in principle) silent. But has nothing to do with Seraglio. Think also of Galatasaray, a most famous sportclub in Istambul,which name also derives from its ancient origin as a Celtic Castle! Now one thinks basketketball and football ( or soccer for our American friends) but its meaning was simply Fortress of the Galats , where the Galats are Celts ! And later the neighbourhoodtook over this name... FYI: As the Celtic tribes first went South from Poland in the past ( must have been around a couple of centuries BC) , they split up in West Europe ( NL- Belgium) into 3 directions: West to England and later Wales and Eire. South to Spain and North Africa (Morocco) East along the Danube ( coins struck 200 B.C near Belgrade Serbia) to Turkey. But that is altogether another story. 3 pictures / drawings are by Th. Valerio in "souvenirs d'un voyage chez les Slaves du Sud “ from 1868 by Georges Perrot. the bearded gent is by unknown in an article "a travers la Bosnie-Herzegovine" dated 1896 by Guillaume Capus and the 5th “ Turkish warrior and Montenegrin” from 1904 Deutsche Alpenzeitung "Wanderungen durch Bosnien, die Hercegowina, Montenegro und Dalmatien." Last edited by gp; 16th May 2020 at 11:56 PM. |
16th May 2020, 10:48 PM | #43 | |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2013
Posts: 2,145
|
Quote:
|
|
16th May 2020, 10:59 PM | #44 | |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2013
Posts: 2,145
|
Quote:
Hi The problem was not about the blade origin or the blade maker but about the silver niello fittings that some members attribute to Greeks without any proof. And even maybe to Christian orthodox Greeks! Glups... Of course we all know that Balkans were Ottoman provinces and partly Muslim. We need more forum members from Turkey to balance a bit the knowledge from the Balkans to Turkey... And never forget that the Balkans were amongst the first provinces of the Ottoman empire so Greek means nothing before the Greek uprising... |
|
17th May 2020, 08:56 AM | #45 | |
Member
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Bay Area
Posts: 1,643
|
Quote:
|
|
17th May 2020, 09:51 AM | #46 | |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2013
Posts: 2,145
|
Quote:
and Turkish is not Ottoman, it's more complicated... If the Balkans are from the Atlantic to the Pacific , then you are perfectly right. Forget about the Greeks: if you talk about an "epirus style" for some daggers, pistols and swords then I'll agree. But again it will depend of what you put under this tag. |
|
17th May 2020, 03:11 PM | #47 |
Member
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Ann Arbor, MI
Posts: 5,503
|
By the way, in Russian, where a good chunk of its vocabulary is of Turkish ( not necessarily Ottoman, but much earlier, back to the Mongolian invasion) the word Sarai ( Сарай) designates not a castle but just a shed, like garden shed. Also, in a slightly modified meaning , “Sarai” is an unkempt, dirty and disorganized living space.
The “Ottoman” origin of all Yataghans in Russian literature was due to the inability of Soviet weapon historians ( such as Astvatsaturian) to visit foreign museums and to talk to foreign colleagues, especially in Yugoslavia: Tito was regarded as a traitor to the great Lenin-Stalin orthodoxy. Greece, after suppression of the communist putsch, was also out of bounds. And, since Bulgaria was “liberated” from the Ottomans by the Russian armies in the 19 century and every “non- Slavic” feature was regarded as Turkish. Thus, Astvatsaturian’s attribution of Ottoman weapons was grossly misinformed and fallacious. Not her fault: the realities of the closed and politicized nature of Communist regime(s). Relatively recent Turkish books, such as the one by Gozde Yasar, perpetuate this narrow view: each and every yataghan there is labeled as Ottoman, with the unspoken implication of being Turkish. No attempt was made to pinpoint decorative features specific to their non-Anatolian origin. Works of Marija Sercer from Zagreb were largely unknown and were not even cited in the above books. Only from a recent book by Dora Boskovic did we learn about Sercer’s major contributions. First time I heard of Bulgarian weapon centers was from the Daskalov’s book. And, finally, the role of Balkan centers was brought to the full view by Elgood. All of them were published and widely available only after collapse of the Soviet Union and redrawing of the maps. Sadly, politics and nationalism play major and destructive role in historical studies. |
17th May 2020, 05:42 PM | #48 | |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2013
Posts: 2,145
|
Quote:
Elgood's book revealed the central role of the Balkans in Ottoman weapon's production. Then we need a map: if you look at this map you will see that the Balkans were amongst the oldest parts of the Ottoman empire. What does it mean? Just that Balkans were Ottomans. The problem with Elgood's book is the title "Arms of Greece" and then many forum members see Greek weapons everywhere whereas in fact these weapons were produced by Albanians, Bosnian, Turkish... |
|
17th May 2020, 06:56 PM | #49 | |
Member
Join Date: May 2020
Posts: 772
|
Quote:
https://yuhistorija.com/int_relations_txt01c1.html As for literature concerning the yataghan : this is all in the eye of the beholder. After Austria’s or better the Habsburg occupation of Bosnia and Hercegowina in 1878, quite some and very valid information can be found (if one masters German) in many publications of “ Wissenschaftliche Mittheilungen aus Bosnien und der Hercegovina “ (= scientific notices ) published in Vienna between 1892/3 and 1916. Also a lot of visitors to the Balkans between 1600 and 1900 did write about their travels with sometimes excellent descriptions and drawings of knives, kamas, bicaqs, yataghans. And due to absence of copyright, legal downloads are available for free , also cheap reprints 22-30 Euro can be bought and the original books for “ the yataghan collector” can be found for a reasonable price . Last edited by gp; 17th May 2020 at 07:44 PM. |
|
17th May 2020, 07:24 PM | #50 | |
Member
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Bay Area
Posts: 1,643
|
Quote:
|
|
17th May 2020, 08:09 PM | #51 |
Member
Join Date: May 2020
Posts: 772
|
some more pics from the book "Starinsko Oruzje"( = old weapons) by Vejsil Curcic , Sarajevo 1926 and one from "la Bosnie l"Herzegovine" by plural writers under supervision of Louis Olivier, Paris 1901.
|
17th May 2020, 08:45 PM | #52 |
Member
Join Date: May 2020
Posts: 772
|
and 3 scans from the occupation war in 1878
|
17th May 2020, 11:14 PM | #53 |
Member
Join Date: May 2020
Posts: 772
|
from Bosnia itself a little about the yataghan:
http://h.etf.unsa.ba/btp/content/muz..._eng/about.htm http://h.etf.unsa.ba/btp/content/muz..._eng/about.htm |
18th May 2020, 07:01 AM | #54 |
Member
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Ann Arbor, MI
Posts: 5,503
|
Thanks, I was unaware of those publications.
However, none of them have been cited by Astvatsaturian or Yasar either. As to your statement that Soviet-Yugoslav relations were rosy till the death of Stalin, please re-read your reference: already in 1948 USSR withdrew all her military and civilian advisers from Yugoslavia and in 1949 the antagonism between the two was already fully apparent. Stalin died in 1953. But be it as it may, Astvatsaturian started her career in the early 50's, and by that time both Yugoslavia and Albania were de facto "traitors " of the Soviet ideology. Contacts with foreign countries were always very limited and difficult for Soviet citizens and collaborations with the " enemies" was practically unheard of. Soviet researchers worked in complete isolation. Add to that their almost universal inability to read and understand foreign languages together with very controlled and limited access to foreign publications even from major libraries, and the picture becomes even more grim. |
18th May 2020, 07:05 AM | #55 | |
Member
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Ann Arbor, MI
Posts: 5,503
|
Quote:
|
|
18th May 2020, 08:07 PM | #56 | |
Member
Join Date: May 2020
Posts: 772
|
Quote:
Although language might also be one botttleneck or showstopper. But a lot of info (of which many are unaware about untill ones visits the places) can be found locally in Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bulgaria, Croatia, Greece, Kosovo, Montenegro, Macedonia, Romania and Serbia . And by the way.... Greek or not to be ( Greek) ? They all are copies from.... the ILLYRIAN SIKA ☺☼☺ Etymology: Possibly from Proto-Albanian *tsikā (whence Albanian thikë, "dagger, knife"), from Proto-Indo-European *ḱey- ("to sharpen") possibly via Illyrian. - According to Dictionnaire des Antiquités Grecques et Romaines the name Sica comes from Proto-Indo-European root sek-, meaning "to cut", "to section", however De Vaan declares any connection to Proto-Indo-European *sek- to be formally impossible. source: Albanian Archaeology 10 August 2019 · Last edited by gp; 18th May 2020 at 08:28 PM. |
|
18th May 2020, 10:01 PM | #57 | |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2013
Posts: 2,145
|
Quote:
I will stay with the Greek kopis, same kind of weapon, same period 5 -4 BC, same area... |
|
18th May 2020, 10:28 PM | #58 | |
Member
Join Date: May 2020
Posts: 772
|
Quote:
but as the Cellts passed through along the Danube... might the origin not be a Celtic faceta...? Last edited by gp; 18th May 2020 at 11:11 PM. |
|
18th May 2020, 10:44 PM | #59 |
Member
Join Date: May 2020
Posts: 772
|
jokes aside...
a legal download althoug I am aware that not everybody can read (Serbian) cyrillic, but worthwile nevertheless and recommendable; "cold weapons of the Ottoman Turcish era: 15-19th century" https://dlscrib.com/queue/hladno-oru...0d60b4272bb181 another legal download in English from an earlier era : https://www.academia.edu/496513/Medi...o_Aleksi%C4%87 and some nice pics of an exhibition in Sarajevo: http://www.novigradsarajevo.ba/news/...1522290?page=4 Last edited by gp; 18th May 2020 at 11:03 PM. |
21st May 2020, 05:50 PM | #60 | |
Member
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Bay Area
Posts: 1,643
|
Quote:
|
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|