Curious marriage: a Kard

ariel · 6th March 2021, 03:16 PM

It depends on your definition of “ deceive”.
Somebody might have made ( or ordered) it for private use as a hunting knife .
Then it went from hands to hands and the original story was forgotten.
Advertising this knife as Central Asian to get more money would be a deceit.
Selling it as a curiosity or relying on the description by the previous “deceiver” would be just ignorance.
There is nothing Central Asian here. Showing examples of other daggers of unknown provenance does not help: this is a usable knife composed of unrelated parts by somebody who was just attributionally ignorant or just didn’ t give a dam ( sic!) about authenticity. Walking stick handle is a good possibility, especially with cheap round glass “stones” on the top.
But, in the immortal words of “ Forged in Fire” , “ It will ke-e- ell” :-)

6th March 2021, 03:16 PM	#21
ariel Member Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Ann Arbor, MI Posts: 5,503	It depends on your definition of “ deceive”. Somebody might have made ( or ordered) it for private use as a hunting knife . Then it went from hands to hands and the original story was forgotten. Advertising this knife as Central Asian to get more money would be a deceit. Selling it as a curiosity or relying on the description by the previous “deceiver” would be just ignorance. There is nothing Central Asian here. Showing examples of other daggers of unknown provenance does not help: this is a usable knife composed of unrelated parts by somebody who was just attributionally ignorant or just didn’ t give a dam ( sic!) about authenticity. Walking stick handle is a good possibility, especially with cheap round glass “stones” on the top. But, in the immortal words of “ Forged in Fire” , “ It will ke-e- ell” :-)