11th August 2012, 12:36 PM | #31 | |
Member
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Paris (FR*) Cairo (EG)
Posts: 1,142
|
Quote:
all these consignments were made there ± 110 years ago, it's easy to imagine, that "Buttin" hadn't our communication facilities to corroborate his informations, not like us actually with the "net" "Buttin" has mentioned often, that some Islamic weapons are rare, (what it's not any more the case in our days ...) but, travelers to Islamic countries of Middle-East, in this century was very few, and some countries was more or less closed to Western peoples, or at least for non-Muslims that might explain a little, imprecisions or perhaps even errors on some of his notes I am well aware of that, but that don't challenge the value bibliographic of the book, in general I will not allow me (I don't have the quality) to comment the written notes of "Buttin", even if I found at my point of view sometimes strange interpretations I strive to meet in my translation, to the mind, against the form of text, no more what I find most interesting in this book, is not so much the comments of "Buttin", but physically, how they was looking like, these islamic edged weapons found about 150 years ago this to me (us) can attempt to determine the oldest weapons forms, to the most recent, however ... if possible all the best my Friend à + Dom |
|
|
|