VERY nicely rebutted GP!!!
As you have well noted, and while not knowing this subject matter specifically nor the history of these regions, I do know Robert Elgood, and that he is one of the finest and most thorough researchers I have ever known.
With these kinds of reference books, and as I have been told by many authors of them, it is inevitable to have certain errors or misperceptions occur as is typically noted in their introductions. Also noted in personal conversations with some authors, is that critics will always loudly voice their self proclaimed expertise in their proclamations.
This is profoundly the case when clear jingoism is at hand.
I have always believed that authors should be applauded for the courage and tenacity it takes to publish, and that any critique or correction should be handled respectfully and with courtesy.
While this discussion has been fascinating and most useful, I just wanted to note these thoughts, and thank GP for adding the obituary of this author with her well deserved respect.
Back to the topic!
|