Quote:
Originally Posted by Ian
Iain,
Thank you again for your knowledge on these swords. Scott Rodell has noted that hilts of circular cross-section, resembling daab from Laos and Thailand, are found on southern Vietnamese swords, compared with more Chinese-styled hilts in the north of Vietnam. Given that the hilts on the sword in the original post and your two examples are round in cross-section and resemble daab somewhat, would you also place these as coming from southern Vietnam (formerly Cochin)?
|
It's certainly possible but I'd caution that I think the shape of handles alone is not a definitive regional indicator and all aspects of each piece need to be considered. For example the handle of a Cham sword that I owned and is now with a good friend was not round but was clearly from south or central Vietnam, while the second handle I am attaching is from the north (I have a clear period photo of the same type).
Just to confuse things a little more I'm adding the handle of a Laos daab that's also not round.
Finally I'd also point out that Vietnamese versions of the dadao also often use round handles, regardless of the north/south divide.