Quote:
Originally Posted by RobT
Gavin Nugent,
As I wrote, I don't see any features on the knife or sheath in question that are inconsistent with the Philippines. That being said, my knowledge of Mexican knives is very limited so I will take your word for it that Mexico is also a possibility. After all, it's not unreasonable to expect knives from two former Spanish colonies to look similar. However, there is that "Del Sr." to account for. If it doesn't stand for Illocos Del Sur in the Philippines, does it stand for a southern Mexican area? I doubt that it is a personal name because "Del Sr." would just translate as "of the senior".
I must however, take issue with your statement that Philippine knives "'typically' have a screw on pommel nut". I looked over my entire collection of Philippine knives with clip point blades (over 16 items) and none of them have a screw on pommel nut. Likewise, none of my double edge Philippine daggers (6 total) have this feature. I have one short sword with a screw on nut but all the rest with a through tang, have the tang peened over a pommel nut or washer.
Sincerely,
RobT
|
Thanks RobT... the shrug icon seems to be a failed icon that no longer appears in print when selected... perhaps the mods can look in to that.... it might have added context
The quillon block are mostly the same, many found in this one forward one back style presented above, as are numerous Gaucho knives too... the blade profile is often the same, most have block forte, although I've encountered others that don't too... the grips come in a variety of types, from single plain horn sections, multiple sections, round, oval, squarish etc... most I recall have the collar at the guard and a capstan pommel...Food for thought at least.
Attached just one example of the type.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sajen
I am with Rob here, I haven't seen so far daggers from the Philippines with a screw. And I also think that "Del Sr" means Illocos Del Sur.
Regards,
Detlef
|
Interesting... IF Del Sur, and if the "u" is added, it would mean "from the south" more than a specific location (Shrug icon inserted).
From the south is the region this knives I note are from, the New Mexico border regions...
Del Sr which I think means "From Mr"... relying on Google translate there, and RobT notes, "Del Sr." would just translate as "of the senior" ... if anyone can offer more insight on the linguistics or possible twists I am interested to learn more.
Gavin
Side note edit...
The grip shape and the way the pommel cap covers the edges, along with the turned waisted collar do have a PI flavour to them.
But equally, the grip shape is not unique to the PI region either (shrug icon inserted)
https://officialalamo.medium.com/mar...e-5c491a3eb3a0