Ethnographic Arms & Armour - View Single Post

Pukka Bundook · 11th January 2016, 01:59 AM

Thank you for all the leg-work in looking up these references Jim!

I see no problem with these differing views of foreign and 'home grown' swords.
It could well be that a country supplying India with good blades in the 17th C. may not be doing so in the 19th century, and visa -versa.

Also, India throughout several centuries has produced excellent blades, But! not maybe Everywhere at the same time, and not always for all ranks.

These things happen in most countries, European or not. :-)

RE bending;
I had a painful lesson in this some time ago;

Had purchased what had been a lovely N. Indian sword, but had been 'cleaned' in an acid bath. (not good)
It had a bend in the blade, and I straightened it over my knee. To my surprise, it straightened out very easily, Too easily as it happened, and had a slight bend the Other way.
I think you know what's coming.
Yes, I nudged it back a little and it fell in two pieces!
The steel looked crystalized and of a very fine grain.
I still remember how I felt at the time. (!)
Anyhow, I contacted a very clever chap in the Czech republic, (who wished to remain anonymous) and he re-joined the blade so one could not tell it was ever broken.
He said the hardness on the Rockwell scale was about 56.

Richard.

11th January 2016, 01:59 AM	#1
Pukka Bundook Member Join Date: Jan 2007 Posts: 803	Thank you for all the leg-work in looking up these references Jim! I see no problem with these differing views of foreign and 'home grown' swords. It could well be that a country supplying India with good blades in the 17th C. may not be doing so in the 19th century, and visa -versa. Also, India throughout several centuries has produced excellent blades, But! not maybe Everywhere at the same time, and not always for all ranks. These things happen in most countries, European or not. :-) RE bending; I had a painful lesson in this some time ago; Had purchased what had been a lovely N. Indian sword, but had been 'cleaned' in an acid bath. (not good) It had a bend in the blade, and I straightened it over my knee. To my surprise, it straightened out very easily, Too easily as it happened, and had a slight bend the Other way. I think you know what's coming. Yes, I nudged it back a little and it fell in two pieces! The steel looked crystalized and of a very fine grain. I still remember how I felt at the time. (!) Anyhow, I contacted a very clever chap in the Czech republic, (who wished to remain anonymous) and he re-joined the blade so one could not tell it was ever broken. He said the hardness on the Rockwell scale was about 56. Richard. Last edited by Pukka Bundook; 11th January 2016 at 02:09 AM.