Another unknown sarong for comment

KLUNGKLUNG · 5th June 2014, 10:05 AM

Dear all,

Here is another Sumatran sarong which I adopted. It came without a blade ( so no further clues thru the blade).
Interesting shape of the sampir (Kemuning kayu) and the edge of the pejetan follows the same concave elegant line as the outline does.
In all only 31 cm tall. Anyone who can enlight me?

BTW>The tip end of the gandar is damaged but repairable.

kai · 6th June 2014, 10:58 AM

Hello Carla,

I believe this is a Minang variant.

I hope Alan doesn't mind me recycling a pic for comparision: While the hilt and sepokal blade got probably imported from Sulawesi Bugis, the scabbard has been tagged as Minang.

Both scabbards exhibit a few differences but I believe they come from the same community. Minang Kabau is a culturally very diverse region with a lot of different keris styles - sorrily still very little research done/published.

Regards,
Kai

KLUNGKLUNG · 7th June 2014, 10:00 PM

Dear Kai,

The sarong of Alan's keris resembles mine indeed but you think the blade plus hilt is assembled with the supposed Minang sarong? From the small(er) size I would say Minang but don't these krisses always have a buntut?
Besides, I am not sure about the gandar being the original part of it. The fitting around the joint is far from perfect...
Far from perfect is the gandar from the herewith depicted other small sarong but I have no doubts gandar and sampir belong together. The shape of the crosspiece is Riau or would you tag this one also as Minang? Got it without a blade again and plan a 'marriage' of both, so please advise ( for both).....

5th June 2014, 10:05 AM	#1
KLUNGKLUNG Member Join Date: Aug 2011 Posts: 24	Another unknown sarong for comment Dear all, Here is another Sumatran sarong which I adopted. It came without a blade ( so no further clues thru the blade). Interesting shape of the sampir (Kemuning kayu) and the edge of the pejetan follows the same concave elegant line as the outline does. In all only 31 cm tall. Anyone who can enlight me? BTW>The tip end of the gandar is damaged but repairable. Attached Images

6th June 2014, 10:58 AM	#2
kai Member Join Date: Apr 2005 Posts: 3,254	Hello Carla, I believe this is a Minang variant. I hope Alan doesn't mind me recycling a pic for comparision: While the hilt and sepokal blade got probably imported from Sulawesi Bugis, the scabbard has been tagged as Minang. Both scabbards exhibit a few differences but I believe they come from the same community. Minang Kabau is a culturally very diverse region with a lot of different keris styles - sorrily still very little research done/published. Regards, Kai Attached Images

7th June 2014, 10:00 PM	#3
KLUNGKLUNG Member Join Date: Aug 2011 Posts: 24	Dear Kai, The sarong of Alan's keris resembles mine indeed but you think the blade plus hilt is assembled with the supposed Minang sarong? From the small(er) size I would say Minang but don't these krisses always have a buntut? Besides, I am not sure about the gandar being the original part of it. The fitting around the joint is far from perfect... Far from perfect is the gandar from the herewith depicted other small sarong but I have no doubts gandar and sampir belong together. The shape of the crosspiece is Riau or would you tag this one also as Minang? Got it without a blade again and plan a 'marriage' of both, so please advise ( for both)..... Attached Images