Ethnographic Arms & Armour
 

Go Back   Ethnographic Arms & Armour > Discussion Forums > Ethnographic Weapons
FAQ Calendar Today's Posts Search

Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
Old 12th July 2016, 01:33 PM   #1
mariusgmioc
Member
 
mariusgmioc's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2014
Location: Austria
Posts: 1,903
Thumbs up Reference: THE ARMS OF GREECE

... AND HER BALKAN NEIGHBOURS IN THE OTTOMAN PERIOD, by Robert Elgood

Just got it and it's brilliant!

A superb reference book on Ottoman weapons, lavishly illustrated, that should be part of every serious collector's library.

Last edited by mariusgmioc; 12th July 2016 at 04:05 PM.
mariusgmioc is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12th July 2016, 04:40 PM   #2
TVV
Member
 
TVV's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Bay Area
Posts: 1,619
Default

Agreed
TVV is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12th July 2016, 04:47 PM   #3
ariel
Member
 
ariel's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Ann Arbor, MI
Posts: 5,503
Default

No argument from me :-)))
ariel is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12th July 2016, 09:43 PM   #4
kahnjar1
Member
 
kahnjar1's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: CHRISTCHURCH NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 2,739
Thumbs up

I agree also....an absolute "must" for the library.
Stu
kahnjar1 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12th July 2016, 10:25 PM   #5
mariusgmioc
Member
 
mariusgmioc's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2014
Location: Austria
Posts: 1,903
Talking

At least we all seem to agree on this one...

How boring...

mariusgmioc is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13th July 2016, 12:38 AM   #6
Jim McDougall
Arms Historian
 
Jim McDougall's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Route 66
Posts: 9,937
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by mariusgmioc
At least we all seem to agree on this one...

How boring...


LOL!!!
Indeed
But here I gotta agree too. The works of Robert Elgood are an absolute must in any arms library. For me, his footnotes alone are a joy. These are 'browsing' books, beyond just being sound references.
The years of research he spent on this book are easily reflected in this volume, and if I recall, there was a big event in Athens as this was officially released.
Jim McDougall is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13th July 2016, 03:14 AM   #7
ariel
Member
 
ariel's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Ann Arbor, MI
Posts: 5,503
Default

I used to dream about a book of Persian arms and armor by Elgood.

But then I understood that it was a fruitless fantasy: Elgood is an ethnologist and an art historian deep in his heart. He thrives in multiethnic, multicultural, multireligious scenery with multiple variants of weapons, structural and artistic changes every 100 miles and every 50 years. Give him a pile of sabers with different handles, swords with blades of dazzling complexity, handles with convoluted religious motives and he will write a 500-page superb book that would read like old John Le Carre.

Persian weapons are beautiful, superbly crafted, but their patterns are terminally uniform and rigid: they achieved what they thought was "perfection" and stayed there. Compare an inexhaustible variety of Indian bladed weapons with the Persian panoply, consisting of shamshir, pesh kabz, khanjar and kard. That's it.

What could Elgood write about them? Twenty pages max.......
ariel is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13th July 2016, 03:54 AM   #8
Jim McDougall
Arms Historian
 
Jim McDougall's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Route 66
Posts: 9,937
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by ariel
I used to dream about a book of Persian arms and armor by Elgood.

But then I understood that it was a fruitless fantasy: Elgood is an ethnologist and an art historian deep in his heart. He thrives in multiethnic, multicultural, multireligious scenery with multiple variants of weapons, structural and artistic changes every 100 miles and every 50 years. Give him a pile of sabers with different handles, swords with blades of dazzling complexity, handles with convoluted religious motives and he will write a 500-page superb book that would read like old John Le Carre.

Persian weapons are beautiful, superbly crafted, but their patterns are terminally uniform and rigid: they achieved what they thought was "perfection" and stayed there. Compare an inexhaustible variety of Indian bladed weapons with the Persian panoply, consisting of shamshir, pesh kabz, khanjar and kard. That's it.

What could Elgood write about them? Twenty pages max.......

But what a twenty six pages it would be!!!!!!
Jim McDougall is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13th July 2016, 06:01 AM   #9
kahnjar1
Member
 
kahnjar1's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: CHRISTCHURCH NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 2,739
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jim McDougall
LOL!!!
Indeed
But here I gotta agree too. The works of Robert Elgood are an absolute must in any arms library. For me, his footnotes alone are a joy. These are 'browsing' books, beyond just being sound references.
The years of research he spent on this book are easily reflected in this volume, and if I recall, there was a big event in Athens as this was officially released.
I agree with you Jim that Elgood's books are both browsing and reference books. I have a number of his works in my small library which from time to time are referred to, or just drooled over!....and of course, and maybe more importantly, the information contained therein is preserved for those who come after us when the present collectors are long passed.
Stu
kahnjar1 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13th July 2016, 10:50 AM   #10
mariusgmioc
Member
 
mariusgmioc's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2014
Location: Austria
Posts: 1,903
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by ariel
I used to dream about a book of Persian arms and armor by Elgood.

...
Maybe you'll better stop dreaming and get "Arms and Armor from Iran" by Manoucher Moshtagh Khorasani... if you don't have it already.
mariusgmioc is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13th July 2016, 12:22 PM   #11
eftihis
Member
 
eftihis's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Chania Crete Greece
Posts: 507
Default

Although i definitely agree that "the arms of Greece end..." it is a valuable book, i have to note that has a lot of mistakes, speaking for the subjects of the book that i have knowledge. For example the authour takes as granted information given by collectors, and especially from the collectors that financed the book. Themselves they got information from antique dealers, that have monetary interest in giving attribution and fake provenance to the pieces they sell...
He also presents fakes as originals, while i would expect from a writer like him to understand the forgeries. As a last weekness of the book ii would say that he gives no information at all for Cretan arms, having only photos of items desribed as cretan without any explanation of why this is so. (characteristics,typology etc)One pistol is labeled as cretan while is Algerian. If i find some time in the next days, i will show you some examples.
eftihis is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13th July 2016, 12:33 PM   #12
mariusgmioc
Member
 
mariusgmioc's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2014
Location: Austria
Posts: 1,903
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by eftihis
Although i definitely agree that "the arms of Greece end..." it is a valuable book, i have to note that has a lot of mistakes, speaking for the subjects of the book that i have knowledge. For example the authour takes as granted information given by collectors, and especially from the collectors that financed the book. Themselves they got information from antique dealers, that have monetary interest in giving attribution and fake provenance to the pieces they sell...
He also presents fakes as originals, while i would expect from a writer like him to understand the forgeries. As a last weekness of the book ii would say that he gives no information at all for Cretan arms, having only photos of items desribed as cretan without any explanation of why this is so. (characteristics,typology etc)One pistol is labeled as cretan while is Algerian. If i find some time in the next days, i will show you some examples.

As I have no deeper knowledge pertaining this topic, I cannot agree or disagree with you, but I would certainly like very much to learn about what your arguments are, in order to educate myself on the subject.

Regards,

Marius

PS: I said earlier that nobody is perfect and we are all prone to making mistakes. (even myself... )
mariusgmioc is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13th July 2016, 01:10 PM   #13
ariel
Member
 
ariel's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Ann Arbor, MI
Posts: 5,503
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by mariusgmioc
Maybe you'll better stop dreaming and get "Arms and Armor from Iran" by Manoucher Moshtagh Khorasani... if you don't have it already.
I have had it for years.

Exactly because of it, I have been dreaming about a book on Persian arms written by a professional:-)))
ariel is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13th July 2016, 02:40 PM   #14
Roland_M
Member
 
Roland_M's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Germany
Posts: 525
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by ariel
Exactly because of it, I have been dreaming about a book on Persian arms written by a professional:-)))
The scientific investigation of and Persian arms and wootz begun in the very late 18th century (George Pearson, 1795) and some years later by Antonio Crivelli from Italy.
This means the scientific knowledge about wootz was gathered, shortly before the production of wootz ended.

All we know from the original wootzmakers are some names like Kirk Narduban, Chora Khorasan and so on but absolutely nothing scientific.

Except from tons of guesses, we know almost nothing for sure.

Try to find out the secret of the dramatic cutting power of a Kilij and Shamshir and you will understand what I mean. Tip: a good Japanese Katana Mei will know the answer, it's more than the deep curvature.


Roland
Roland_M is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13th July 2016, 03:16 PM   #15
digenis
Member
 
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 48
Default

I enjoyed the book. However, I do think the author shortchanged actual Greek weapons manufacture, silver smith work from Jannina in Epirus and as previously mentioned Cretan and island work in general. In a way I think the book is "lazy" since in only discusses broadly known facts about Balkan weapons manufacturing centers. A good reference book but I think the author missed an opportunity to write the holy grail of Ottoman weapons cataloging national characteristics to the greatest degree possible. But then that would suck part of the air out of this forum...
digenis is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14th July 2016, 12:05 AM   #16
ariel
Member
 
ariel's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Ann Arbor, MI
Posts: 5,503
Default

Roland_M,

Can we concentrate on the book, please?

If you want to start a thread about practical advantages of wootz, shamshirs etc., I am sure you will find quite a lot of people to talk to.
We had these discussions ( often very heated ones) for years and they never failed to attract participants.
ariel is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:14 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Posts are regarded as being copyrighted by their authors and the act of posting material is deemed to be a granting of an irrevocable nonexclusive license for display here.