Sumatra sword , sikin parang

[tom22]

H

[David R]

Nice, thanks for posting.

[Sajen]

Originally Posted by tom22

H

I saw your thread two days ago but hadn't the time to comment and just wanted to do it but you have removed the pictures!

Sometimes you need a little bit of patience, the interest you can see by the views!

[Sajen]

I've noticed that some people don't show patience when they post their items and show disappointment afterwards when their posts don't get comments.
I know this from myself, see for example here: http://www.vikingsword.com/vb/showth...highlight=alor
I've posted the shield in March and got until now not one single comment but over 2000 views, so it seems that there is some interest.
But why did it receive no comments? By my shield maybe because it's a rare item and most of the people never have seen such a shield before!?
But why don't get this nice sikin (so far I remember) no comments? Maybe because there was no question added and we have seen some others before? I only can advise to show a little bit of patience when new members post their items!

[JeffS]

I think patience is needed. This is not a huge nor highly active forum and members come and go. Also, the knowlege is highly specialized so many members may not have anwers or even educated comments, they are here to learn. I often read and appreciate posts but have nothing to add. On some, I make a mental note to come back and add my example when I photograph it. I see posts with no response get picked up after a long time when another member finds it on a search. If keen to get a comment, bumping also works well. This forum format works at a different pace than most other social media that may have more immediate response and activity but provides little to no archival value nor captures comments across a long period of time. I hope frequent posters do not get discouraged by lack of immediate feedback. Too bad there isn't a "like" button so at least people can flag appreciation even if they don't have anything to say.

[tom22]

Sorry all , I guess I've been too impatient , I havnt posted many pieces on here ,in fact only one post , I saw there had been alot of views and no comments ,so I guessed it wasn't much interest to anyone , will see if I can upload pics again

[Battara]

You could repost. Some folks have no idea what to say too.

[Sajen]

Originally Posted by tom22

Sorry all , I guess I've been too impatient , I havnt posted many pieces on here ,in fact only one post , I saw there had been alot of views and no comments ,so I guessed it wasn't much interest to anyone , will see if I can upload pics again

It would be great when you share pictures of your sikin panjang again!

I have in my collection two of these type, you can them see here: http://www.vikingsword.com/vb/showth...=sikin+panjang

Regards,
Detlef

[DaveF]

Here are my three Northern Sumatra/Aceh swords. From the top:

1. Co Jang
2. Sikin Panjang
3. Amanremu

The co jang and sikin panjang are laminated while the amanremu appears not to be, with an edge that seems differentially hardened. No scabbards unfortunately, though I believe the co jangs traditionally weren't in a scabbard. None of them feel cumbersome in the hand, though the co jang has a bit more heft to it.

It would be nice to see how the sikin panjang compares to Tom22's.

[Pendita65]

Hi Dave,

some really nice swords you have, and how are the hilts, No dry cracks?

Regards, Martin

[DaveF]

Originally Posted by Pendita65

Hi Dave,

some really nice swords you have, and how are the hilts, No dry cracks?

Regards, Martin

I'm afraid they've all got a crack, Martin. They're not too bad and I've not tried to treat them other than regular rubs with raw lanolin in the hope that it'll reduce the chance of the cracks worsening. I must have read somewhere that that helps. I've just seen soaking in baby oil recommended as a lengthy treatment. ( http://www.vikingsword.com/vb/showthread.php?t=12008 ) . Any suggestions?

[kronckew]

My sikin, modern made by one of the few remaining smiths in the mountains near the Aceh area for a local dealer I have bought a few other items from. He was reducing his own collection and offered/sold me this one. Sadly haven't heard from him since the tsunami.

[Ian]

My examples are shown here

[JeffS]

Photo of mine from my database.

[Maurice]

Originally Posted by DaveF

I'm afraid they've all got a crack, Martin. They're not too bad and I've not tried to treat them other than regular rubs with raw lanolin in the hope that it'll reduce the chance of the cracks worsening. I must have read somewhere that that helps. I've just seen soaking in baby oil recommended as a lengthy treatment. ( http://www.vikingsword.com/vb/showthread.php?t=12008 ) . Any suggestions?

No worries, I've never seen old ones like these with no age cracks. Nice group of swords!

Regards,
Maurice

[Maurice]

Originally Posted by tom22

Sorry all , I guess I've been too impatient , I havnt posted many pieces on here ,in fact only one post , I saw there had been alot of views and no comments ,so I guessed it wasn't much interest to anyone , will see if I can upload pics again

Thank you Tom, would be nice to have a look at your find!

Regards,
Maurice

[Sajen]

Hello Tom,

Please repost your nice sword!

Regards,
Detlef

[DaveF]

Originally Posted by Maurice

No worries, I've never seen old ones like these with no age cracks. Nice group of swords!

Regards,
Maurice

Thanks, Maurice. I've a couple of swords with black horn hilts that haven't cracked. Maybe they're not as old, or do some types of horn crack more readily than others?

[Maurice]

Originally Posted by DaveF

Thanks, Maurice. I've a couple of swords with black horn hilts that haven't cracked. Maybe they're not as old, or do some types of horn crack more readily than others?

Most of the Achenese gliwangs I have seen had age cracks (some cracks larger and wider than others).
Probably, because of the heavy and thick blades, these types often have larger cracks than other Indonesion swords with horn hilts.
Some cracks are filled with some kind of substance (wax or other material in the same colour as the hilt), put in there by collectors or dealers to mask the crack.

[Maurice]

Some have large cracks, some have minor cracks and some have no cracks or filled cracks.

Here an amanermoe in my collection with a minor crack.

[Maurice]

And one of my Roedoïh oelèë Tjangge with minor crack.

[Maurice]

Sikin Peusangan with hilt crack