Ethnographic Arms & Armour - View Single Post

Conogre · 18th May 2005, 06:51 AM

Bump.
I'm truly surprised that this one has garnered so little comment in both posts, by Justin and myself.
My primary thought on it, Tom, is simple awe over the size of it and the extreme quality amd intricacy of the metalwork.
The "jewels" appear to be glass, each with silver edges welded all the way around it to hold them in place, not plastic as in the typical "T-word" bazaar pieces, with the four round ones 1/2" across and the long rectangular red one a full 1 1/2" long, and even the thick brass affixing rings are extremely detailed.
The blade on this one is unsharpened, but not "flat" as in so many tourist pieces, with a definite taper toward the edges, more in the line of an unissued military sword with the brass "ferule" actually welded onto both sides of the blade.....the blade is also nearly twice the thickness of a traditional jambiya blade as well, by the way, actually thicker than both my kaskara and takouba.
Even estimating age on this one is extremely difficult, as whomever had it kept it in nearly pristine condition with none of the usual indicators of age present, while at the same time, not conspicuoisly absent, if that makes any sense.
I keep hoping that Artzi or one of the other middle eastern sages will notice and at least give me their impressions.
One possibility, of course, is that it was made for display purposes to showcase his abilities by a craftesman hoping to attract high end consignees, such as those 3' balisongs from Manilla, with another being that it was made simply as a presentation piece for a highly regarded dignitary or friend.
In all truthfullness, I find it hard to visualize anyone actually using this simply because it is so heavy and unwieldy, whle it would DEFINITELY work if one was going strictly for prestige or impressiveness.
Mike

18th May 2005, 06:51 AM	#3
Conogre Member Join Date: Feb 2005 Location: Clearwater, Florida Posts: 371	Bump. I'm truly surprised that this one has garnered so little comment in both posts, by Justin and myself. My primary thought on it, Tom, is simple awe over the size of it and the extreme quality amd intricacy of the metalwork. The "jewels" appear to be glass, each with silver edges welded all the way around it to hold them in place, not plastic as in the typical "T-word" bazaar pieces, with the four round ones 1/2" across and the long rectangular red one a full 1 1/2" long, and even the thick brass affixing rings are extremely detailed. The blade on this one is unsharpened, but not "flat" as in so many tourist pieces, with a definite taper toward the edges, more in the line of an unissued military sword with the brass "ferule" actually welded onto both sides of the blade.....the blade is also nearly twice the thickness of a traditional jambiya blade as well, by the way, actually thicker than both my kaskara and takouba. Even estimating age on this one is extremely difficult, as whomever had it kept it in nearly pristine condition with none of the usual indicators of age present, while at the same time, not conspicuoisly absent, if that makes any sense. I keep hoping that Artzi or one of the other middle eastern sages will notice and at least give me their impressions. One possibility, of course, is that it was made for display purposes to showcase his abilities by a craftesman hoping to attract high end consignees, such as those 3' balisongs from Manilla, with another being that it was made simply as a presentation piece for a highly regarded dignitary or friend. In all truthfullness, I find it hard to visualize anyone actually using this simply because it is so heavy and unwieldy, whle it would DEFINITELY work if one was going strictly for prestige or impressiveness. Mike Attached Images Last edited by Conogre; 18th May 2005 at 07:07 AM.