Quote:
|
Originally Posted by katana
the size of the hilts is another 'hotly' debated subject ..there are several posts on the Forum.....here is one that I posted...
|
I am aware of this discussion, as i even posted some humble coments on this thread. Actually i have now brought these handling pictures in order to complement the said frequent discussion. To my poor view there is no doubt that the small Indian hilt subject is a fusion of two distinct phenomena. Among various resources, i remember Rainer Dahenhart's book HOMENS ESPADAS E TOMATES (page 191):
In the northern Indo-Portuguse territories ( Diu, Damão, Baçaim, Dadra, Nagar-Haveli ) the tulwar was used, but only in the hands of local nobility and auxiliary indigenous forces. The Portuguese weren't using this weapon, firstly because they had more confidence in their own, bu also because the majority of tulwar grips are so small that only few Portuguese hands would fit into them ( pics. 51, 52 and 100 ).
On the other hand, the acceptance of this concept might have been adultered by the introduction of the ricasso, probably brought in by Europeans with their swords. We know that in some cases the ricasso efectiveness was only virtual. In Cingalese kastanes the ricasso is there and was efectively brought by the Portuguese , but the down quillons were so withered that it only served for decoration. This because they never needed this alternative, as they didn't adopt the corresponding fencing techniques. However while i was browsing the Net to look for material on my tulwar, i have read that the majority of tulwar holders in existing pictures, are handling the sword with their forefinger out the hilt and onto the ricasso.
We remember that this system enabled for a much wider angle of sword holding, an advantage that ended up enabling the thrust, which would put the foe without this system in a very weak situation in combat.
Allow me to through some logs onto the fire and post the pages referring to this evolution, within an European perspective,from the same quoted book.