View Single Post
Old 4th August 2025, 10:50 PM   #3
Jim McDougall
Arms Historian
 
Jim McDougall's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Route 66
Posts: 10,486
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by urbanspaceman View Post
Border Reivers' swords???
Peter and I have been positing this explanation for a long time now:
One of the solutions to Border Reiving was to encourage the leaders to remove the problem.
In 1603 Walter Scott of Buccleuch took 2,000 Reivers to fight “The Belgic Wars” and to become mercenaries in Europe’s religious and political conflicts.
In the 30 Years War the great Swedish king Gustavus Adolphus ascribed much of his military success to the “steadfastness and grit of his Scottish mercenaries”. He made their leader Alexander Leslie a field-marshal in the Swedish army.
n.b.
Walter Scott of Buccleuch – ‘The Bold Buccleuch’. Leader of Kinmont Willie’s raid.
Alexander Leslie 1st Earl of Leven.
Too much to post here; look up these Guys on Wikipedia.

Had you guys EXACTLY in mind in posting this!
These rugged clans were formidable warriors who lived independent of national loyalties, and would often align with certain powers much in the manner of the landsknechts of Europe who were actively mercenary forces.
Their excellence as light cavalry with the small 'Galloway' ponies and use of a broad spectrum of arms and armor from Europe remained in their use long after their recognized 'heydey'. .....and they continued as always despite being less formally organized.
While groups of men recognized as 'Reivers' are not specifically documented in records of Culloden, their ancestors certainly were there in some numbers. It is likely that these men may well have had old family weapons with them on the field, or in any of the ensuing actions before and after the battle which of course would have occurred in the environs. Of the thousands of Jacobite forces in the battle proper, after the battle only 191 swords were recovered from the field. This begs the question....where did the rest go???

There was more than camraderie among the Jacobite forces, these men were far more than just clansmen, but families. Fathers, sons, brothers who fought together, and of those who fell, they would not leave their sacred family swords on the field, and they were it appears in large part taken away. Of these 191 swords somehow left, these suffered the travesty most feared, and as many as 138 were dismounted, the blades fashioned into a garish fence for an English estate at Twickenham. In 1894 these were discovered and Lord Archibald Campbell wrote about them in his book, "Scottish Swords from the Battlefield at Culloden", with many of these blades cleaned and somewhat restored. As far as I have known these blades are held at the castle at Inverary to date, and none have ever been formally studied or published.

Last edited by Jim McDougall; 5th August 2025 at 12:51 AM.
Jim McDougall is offline   Reply With Quote