A question of this nature becomes a matter of opinion, rather than something that can be positively determined one way or the other.
My opinion is that planar hilts existed prior to the influence of Islam on hilt design. The Islamic influence was the incorporation of cecekan.
Planar hilts can be found in Javanese weapons other than keris, and the Balinese forms of planar hilt certainly owe nothing to any Islamic input.
|