Ethnographic Arms & Armour

Ethnographic Arms & Armour (http://www.vikingsword.com/vb/index.php)
-   European Armoury (http://www.vikingsword.com/vb/forumdisplay.php?f=12)
-   -   Curious cuirass (http://www.vikingsword.com/vb/showthread.php?t=29063)

cel7 6th August 2023 03:17 PM

Curious cuirass
 
4 Attachment(s)
I have here the breastplate of a Bavarian or Prussian cuirass M1842 or 1845 I believe. Nothing special, I see them often. However, this one has something strange, the right shoulder piece is considerably narrower than the one for the left shoulder. This is certainly not standard, it has been adjusted afterwards. You can still see where they hammered the edge into shape and even a stress crack. The only reason I can think of for this is that the user was right-handed and found it helpful if he had a little more room to swing his weapon. Has anyone ever seen anything like this with standard cuirasses?

kronckew 7th August 2023 09:56 AM

The ding in the centre musta been a bit uncomfortable.:eek:

fernando 7th August 2023 02:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cel7 (Post 283671)
... The only reason I can think of for this is that the user was right-handed and found it helpful if he had a little more room to swing his weapon...

Could be ... and should be, until a better diagnosis comes up.
On the other hand, that indentation in the center of the chest could be someone's later invention. Besides being so 'precisely' located, i wonder whether this shot test was still a procedure by the 19th. century.

cel7 7th August 2023 05:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fernando (Post 283692)
Could be ... and should be, until a better diagnosis comes up.
On the other hand, that indentation in the center of the chest could be someone's later invention. Besides being so 'precisely' located, i wonder whether this shot test was still a procedure by the 19th. century.


yes it was. I don't understand the point of it either, but the "German" cuirasses seem to have it all. More or less in the same place.

Victrix 7th August 2023 08:57 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by cel7 (Post 283695)
yes it was. I don't understand the point of it either, but the "German" cuirasses seem to have it all. More or less in the same place.

Same with the Swedish ones. Mine is end 17thC-beginning/18thC Carolingean era cavalry breast plate. Maybe the Swedes and the Germans took the term “bullet proof” just literally. In Sweden this was an official requirement to demonstrate the effectiveness of the kit. On the inside it’s marked with a crown and weight. There’s a small smith’s mark in the centre just below the collar. It’s very heavy at around 7kg.

cel7 8th August 2023 03:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Victrix (Post 283699)
Same with the Swedish ones. Mine is end 17thC-beginning/18thC Carolingean era cavalry breast plate. Maybe the Swedes and the Germans took the term “bullet proof” just literally. In Sweden this was an official requirement to demonstrate the effectiveness of the kit. On the inside it’s marked with a crown and weight. There’s a small smith’s mark in the centre just below the collar. It’s very heavy at around 7kg.

That's a very nice cuirass you have there!

fernando 8th August 2023 04:59 PM

3 Attachment(s)
Yes, a rather impressive example indeed. Vitrix, allow me to repost your picture in the upright position. Amazing how i was more used to see these shot strikes looking so deepening, and in your example its outline looks so shallow and circumscript, so to say ... even with inscriptions inserted. New to me, but no wonder; my experience with these is so scarce.


´.

Victrix 8th August 2023 08:41 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by fernando (Post 283711)
Yes, a rather impressive example indeed. Vitrix, allow me to repost your picture in the upright position. Amazing how i was more used to see these shot strikes looking so deepening, and in your example its outline looks so shallow and circumscript, so to say ... even with inscriptions inserted. New to me, but no wonder; my experience with these is so scarce.


´.

Many thanks for rotating the picture Fernando! It was shot with a musket lead bullet which flattens on impact (muskets had fairly short range as well in those days). The breast plates were worn over tough buff coats made from moose skin. I understand the breast plates were unpopular due to their weight @7Kg! I took this picture in the Summer when I visited the city of Lund which was the scene of the bloodiest battle on Swedish soil when the Danes tried to re-take the Southern Swedish region of Skåne (Lat. Scania). The shoulder strap is to hang the cavalry carbine on.

Victrix 8th August 2023 08:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cel7 (Post 283710)
That's a very nice cuirass you have there!

Thank you! Yours is nice too. Maybe it belonged to Kaiser Wilhelm? I understand he had something wrong with his arm.

Akanthus 8th August 2023 08:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Victrix (Post 283719)
Thank you! Yours is nice too. Maybe it belonged to Kaiser Wilhelm? I understand he had something wrong with his arm.

Was his left arm....

Victrix 8th August 2023 09:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Akanthus (Post 283720)
Was his left arm....

:cool:

fernando 9th August 2023 02:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Victrix (Post 283719)
Thank you! Yours is nice too. Maybe it belonged to Kaiser Wilhelm? I understand he had something wrong with his arm.

Yes, this would make cel7 assumption plausible; if it wasn't for the fact that the Kaiser with the uselless left arm was Wilhem the second (1859/1941), Emperor since 1888; a bit too late for the use of a cuirass, and as he isn't recorded to have engaged in combat episodes... i think. If he used one for parade events, i would realize that an Emperor's cerimony cuirass would have a rather more embellished aspect.



.

fernando 12th August 2023 09:36 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Gentlemen, don't tie me to the whipping post. I just saw an oil painting by Paul Beckert (1890) of Kaiser Willem II wearing a breast plate... posing for the artist; his left hand resting on his waist.


.

Akanthus 16th August 2023 01:22 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by fernando (Post 283777)
Gentlemen, don't tie me to the whipping post. I just saw an oil painting by Paul Beckert (1890) of Kaiser Willem II wearing a breast plate... posing for the artist; his left hand resting on his waist.


.

Yes,Fernando .This cuirass is much more elegant than the ones of the common soldiers.It's the uniform of the Garde du Corps,the first and finest cuirassier regiment in Prussia at this time.Look at the eagle helmet.

Victrix 16th September 2023 04:34 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by Victrix (Post 283718)
Many thanks for rotating the picture Fernando! It was shot with a musket lead bullet which flattens on impact (muskets had fairly short range as well in those days). The breast plates were worn over tough buff coats made from moose skin. I understand the breast plates were unpopular due to their weight @7Kg! I took this picture in the Summer when I visited the city of Lund which was the scene of the bloodiest battle on Swedish soil when the Danes tried to re-take the Southern Swedish region of Skåne (Lat. Scania). The shoulder strap is to hang the cavalry carbine on.

The Royal Swedish Life Guard still uses the 17thC breastplates for ceremonial duty like today on the occasion of H.M. the King’s 50th year anniversary on the throne.

Back in the day these soldiers formed the king’s closest body guard in battle. They were all hand-picked officers with outstanding battle merits who served as privates in the unit. Although cavalry, they are dismounted when on ceremonial duty and characteristically stamp their heavy cavalry boots in unison when they march which causes quite a noise.

Richard G 16th September 2023 05:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cel7 (Post 283671)
I have here the breastplate of a Bavarian or Prussian cuirass M1842 or 1845 I believe. Nothing special, I see them often. However, this one has something strange, the right shoulder piece is considerably narrower than the one for the left shoulder. This is certainly not standard, it has been adjusted afterwards. You can still see where they hammered the edge into shape and even a stress crack. The only reason I can think of for this is that the user was right-handed and found it helpful if he had a little more room to swing his weapon. Has anyone ever seen anything like this with standard cuirasses?

I wonder if it was to help out someone who was expected to keep their right arm permanently or semi-permanently raised. a flag or standard bearer, trumpeter, or something like that.
Best wishes
Richard


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:17 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Posts are regarded as being copyrighted by their authors and the act of posting material is deemed to be a granting of an irrevocable nonexclusive license for display here.